China and England: On the Structural Convergence of Political Values [Book Review]
Journal of World Philosophies 5 (1):188-195 (2020)
Abstract
At the centre of Powers' (2019) China and England is an extraordinary forgotten episode in the history of political ideas. There was a time when English radicals critiqued the corruption and injustice of the English political system by contrasting it with the superior example of China. There was a time when they advocated adopting a Chinese conceptual framework for thinking about politics. So dominant and prevalent was the English radicals' use of this framework, that their opponents took to dismissing their points as 'the argument from the Chinese'. In my review of Powers' book, I welcome the profound reconfiguration of our political understandings that knowledge of this historical episode brings. However, I question Powers' framing presumption that the generic problems of any complex society lead to convergence on a single master political value of 'social justice'. Surely there are deep and enduring differences amongst thinkers of political value, even within a single society, let alone across different societies. Taking this point seriously would challenge the simple linear directionality of Powers' story of moral and political progress.Author's Profile
My notes
Similar books and articles
The Political History Tradition of China Ancient Historiography.Qiu-Sheng Zhang - 2007 - Nankai University (Philosophy and Social Sciences) 3:103-112.
The East Asian Challenge for Democracy: Political Meritocracy in Comparative Perspective.Daniel A. Bell & Chenyang Li (eds.) - 2013 - Cambridge University Press.
Meritocracy as a Political System: A Commentary on Bell's The China Model.Binfan Wang - 2019 - Philosophy East and West 69 (2):577-585.
China: The Political Philosophy of the Middle Kingdom by Bai Tongdong (review).David Elstein - 2014 - Philosophy East and West 64 (2):513-515.
Bell's Model of Meritocracy for China: Two Confucian Amendments.Yong Huang - 2019 - Philosophy East and West 69 (2):559-568.
Liu Zehua and Studies of China's Monarchism: Guest Editor's Introduction.Yuri Pines - 2013 - Contemporary Chinese Thought 45 (2-3):3-20.
Revolution by Degrees: James Tyrell and Whig Political Thought in Late Seventeenth Century.Julia Rudolph - 2002 - Palgrave.
Chinese Value and its World Meaning.Kang Ouyang - 2018 - Proceedings of the XXIII World Congress of Philosophy 47:167-174.
The Spirit of Strauss' Political Philosophy and the Reconstruction of Chinese Tradition.Kai-Xian Chen - 2006 - Modern Philosophy 3:56-62.
The Most Fashionable and the Most Relevant: A Review of Contemporary Chinese Political Philosophy. [REVIEW]Zhou Lian - 2009 - Diogenes 56 (1):128-137.
Analytics
Added to PP
2020-06-03
Downloads
196 (#66,029)
6 months
32 (#40,067)
2020-06-03
Downloads
196 (#66,029)
6 months
32 (#40,067)
Historical graph of downloads