Journal of Philosophical Research 17:155-172 (1992)
AbstractAgainst recent commentators such as Annstrong, D’Arcy, Copleston, O’Connor, Bourke, and Grisez, I argue that the logic referred to by Thomas in his “Treatise on Law” should not be understood metaphorically. Instead, it involves a chain of syllogisms, beginning with the synderesis principle, followed by primary, secondary, and tertiary principles, and ends with a practical syllogism. In showing this, I attack the view that the synderesis principle, “good ought to be done and evil avoided,” is tautological. Second, I show the syllogistic relation between this and the more subordinate moral principIes. Finally, I argue that the practical syllogism also involves a logical deduction, where the minor premise is a propositional attitude of perception, and the conclusion is an action which expresses a proposition. What emerges is a more precise account of how actions are related to natural law.
Similar books and articles
The Logic of Natural Law in Aquinas’s “Treatise on Law”.James F. Fieser - 1992 - Journal of Philosophical Research 17:155-172.
Is There Anything Logically Distinctive About Practical Syllogisms?Jean-Baptiste Gourinat - 2009 - History of Philosophy & Logical Analysis 12.
Is There Anything Logically Distinctive About Practical Syllogisms?Jean-Baptiste Gourinat - 2008 - History of Philosophy & Logical Analysis 11.
The First Principles of Natural Law a Study of the Moral Theories of Aristotle and Saint Thomas Aquinas. --.Maria Theresa Carl - 1990 - University Microfilms International.
Intrinsically Evil Actions According to St. Thomas Aquinas.Steven John Jensen - 1993 - Dissertation, University of Notre Dame
Commentary on Thomas Aquinas's Treatise on Law.J. Budziszewski - 2014 - New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.
Practical Syllogism in Context. De Motu 7 and Zoology.Pierre Morel - 2009 - History of Philosophy & Logical Analysis 12.
Practical Syllogism in Context. De Motu 7 and Zoology.Pierre Morel - 2008 - History of Philosophy & Logical Analysis 11.
Love and the First Principles of St. Thomas's Natural Law.R. Mary Hayden - 1988 - Dissertation, University of St. Thomas (Houston)
The Foundation of Moral Reasoning: The Development of the Doctrine of Universal Moral Principles in the Works of Thomas Aquinas and his Predecessors.Anthony Celano - 2013 - Diametros 38:1-61.
The Natural Law Constructed in the System of Aquinas's Virtue Ethics.Hsiao-Huei Pan - 2011 - Philosophy and Culture 38 (4):25-43.
Hume's Foundational Project in the Treatise.Miren Boehm - 2016 - European Journal of Philosophy 24 (1):55-77.
Law as an Extrinsic Principle of Action in Aquinas.John A. D. Cuddeback - 1997 - Dissertation, The Catholic University of America
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads