Inconsistencies in Glaucon’s Account of Justice

Polis 24 (1):43-69 (2007)
  Copy   BIBTEX

Abstract

This paper identifies major inconsistencies in the threefold argument that Glaucon presents in defence of Thrasymachus in the second book of Plato’s Republic. Specifically, the paper argues for three claims. Firstly, it argues that in his account of the origin of justice Glaucon treats the consequences of justice as necessary, while in the test case he merely emphasizes incidental consequences. Secondly, the paper argues that in setting up the test case of the perfectly unjust man and the perfectly just man Glaucon—despite claiming to be restating Thrasymachus’ claims, and also to be presenting the ordinary view of justice — uses some Socratic assumptions about the nature of justice. That is, although Gyges’ example follows directly from the first part of the argument and, in particular, from the claim that justice is grounded in convention, the unshakably just man of the test example is supposed to be motivated by justice itself. Finally, it is argued that the test case and Gyges' example are at variance with respect to public recognition: in the test case Glaucon suggests that most people would respect and admire a man who seemed to be perfectly just, while in his discussion of Gyges he intimates that tyrannical power strengthens itself not by the false appearance of perfect justice, but by appealing to a secret and yet widespread admiration for unpunished injustice.

Links

PhilArchive



    Upload a copy of this work     Papers currently archived: 74,594

External links

Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server

Through your library

Similar books and articles

O Contrato De Gláucon.Luiz Maurício Bentim da Rocha Menezes - 2017 - Trans/Form/Ação 40 (1):235-252.
Happiness and Justice in Plato's "Republic".Randall Mark Jensen - 1997 - Dissertation, University of California, Los Angeles
Storytelling and Philosophy in Plato’s Republic.Jacob Howland - 2005 - American Catholic Philosophical Quarterly 79 (2):213-232.
Glaucon's Question Ignored: Republic 519a-521b.James Butler - 2018 - AKROPOLIS: Journal of Hellenic Studies 2:46-66.
Plato's Ethics and Politics in the Republic.Eric Brown - 2008 - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.

Analytics

Added to PP
2019-05-25

Downloads
13 (#760,424)

6 months
3 (#211,070)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author's Profile

Alessandra Fussi
University of Pisa

Citations of this work

No citations found.

Add more citations