Argumentation 26 (3):393-407 (2012)
An argument can be superficially valid and rhetorically effective even if what is plausibly meant, what is derived from what, and how it is derived is not at all clear. An example of such an argument is provided by Socrates’s famous refutation of Euthyphro’s second definition of holy, which is generally regarded as clearly valid and successful. This paper provides a stricter logical analysis than the ones in the literature. In particular, it is shown that the argument contains a syntactically ambiguous expression, a passage that needs to be read charitably, and a previously unnoticed but crucial shift between two notions of unholy. Different analyses may be provided, depending on how these interpretation problems are solved. The conditions under which the refutation is valid and successful are far from obvious, and are here explicitly specified
|Keywords||Socrates Validity Ambiguity Rhetoric|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
References found in this work BETA
Socratic Wisdom: The Model of Knowledge in Plato's Early Dialogues.Hugh H. Benson - 2000 - Oxford University Press.
Citations of this work BETA
No citations found.
Similar books and articles
Socrates on the Definition of Piety.S. Marc Cohen - 1971 - Journal of the History of Philosophy 9 (1):1-13.
Logical Form.Christopher Menzel - 1998 - In Edward Craig (ed.), Routledge Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Routledge.
A Partisan's Guide to Socratic Intellectualism.Matthew Evans - 2010 - In Sergio Tenenbaum (ed.), Desire, Practical Reason, and the Good. Oxford University Press. pp. 6.
Informal Reasoning and Logical Formalization.Michael Baumgartner - 2010 - In S. Conrad & S. Imhof (eds.), Ding und Begriff. Ontos.
The Euthyphro Argument (9d–11b).Brendan O'Sullivan - 2006 - Southern Journal of Philosophy 44 (4):657-675.
The Soft-Line Solution to Pereboom's Four-Case Argument.Kristin Mickelson - 2010 - Australasian Journal of Philosophy 88 (4):595-617.
Prajñākaragupta on the Two Truths and Argumentation.Hisayasu Kobayashi - 2011 - Journal of Indian Philosophy 39 (4-5):427-439.
Protagoras Refuted: How Clever is Socrates' "Most Clever" Argument at Theaetetus 171a–C?Luca Castagnoli - 2004 - Topoi 23 (1):3-32.
Socrates and Euthyphro: The Argument and its Revival.Terence Irwin - 2006 - In Lindsay Judson & V. Karasmanēs (eds.), Remembering Socrates: Philosophical Essays. Oxford University Press.
Is Imperative Inference Impossible? The Argument From Permissive Presuppositions.Hannah Clark-Younger - 2012 - In James Maclaurin (ed.), Rationis Defensor.
Added to index2012-04-09
Total downloads14 ( #319,879 of 2,143,791 )
Recent downloads (6 months)1 ( #387,161 of 2,143,791 )
How can I increase my downloads?
There are no threads in this forum
Nothing in this forum yet.