Let Us Be Fair to 5-Year-Olds: Priority for the Young in the Allocation of Scarce Health Resources

Public Health Ethics 11 (3):325-335 (2018)
  Copy   BIBTEX

Abstract

Life-saving health resources like organs for transplant and experimental medications are persistently scarce. How ought we, morally speaking, to ration these resources? Many hold that, in any morally acceptable allocation scheme, the young should to some extent be prioritized over the old. Govind Persad, Alan Wertheimer and Ezekiel Emanuel propose a multi-principle allocation scheme called the Complete Lives System, according to which persons roughly between 15 and 40 years old get priority over younger children and older adults, other things being equal. They defend this ‘modified youngest first’ principle in part by appealing to the greater social investment that has been made in 15-year-olds than in younger children. Ruth Tallman has proposed a distinctive defense of modified youngest first, one that appeals not at all to social investment. We find this defense wanting. Tallman’s argument depends on the idea, which we try to show to be implausible, that allocations should maximize the number of people in the midst of a possibly complete life who actually complete their lives. Moreover, Tallman does not justify the priority modified youngest first gives 15-year-olds over, for example, 5-year-olds. Tallman fails to dispel a serious shortcoming with modified youngest first: its fundamental unfairness to pre-adolescents.

Other Versions

No versions found

Links

PhilArchive



    Upload a copy of this work     Papers currently archived: 97,119

External links

Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server

Through your library

Similar books and articles

Complete lives in the balance.Samuel J. Kerstein & Greg Bognar - 2010 - American Journal of Bioethics 10 (4):37 – 45.

Analytics

Added to PP
2018-05-26

Downloads
48 (#358,385)

6 months
14 (#356,513)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author Profiles

Samuel Kerstein
University of Maryland, College Park
Kelsey Gipe
University of Maryland, College Park

Citations of this work

Healthcare Priorities: The “Young” and the “Old”.Ben Davies - 2023 - Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics 32 (2):174-185.

Add more citations

References found in this work

Equality and priority.Derek Parfit - 1997 - Ratio 10 (3):202–221.
Life's Dominion.Melissa Lane & Ronald Dworkin - 1994 - Philosophical Quarterly 44 (176):413.
The Value of Life.John Harris - 1985 - Mind 95 (380):533-535.
The Value of Life: An Introduction to Medical Ethics.John Harris - 1985 - Tijdschrift Voor Filosofie 49 (4):699-700.

View all 18 references / Add more references