Philosophy of Science 46 (4):559-589 (1979)
Many philosophers, both past and present, object to materialism not from any romantic anti-scientific bent, but from sheer inability to understand the thesis. It seems utterly inconceivable to some that qualia should exist in a world which is entirely material. This paper investigates the grain objection, a much neglected argument which purports to prove that sensations could not be brain events. Three versions are examined in great detail. The plausibility of the first version is shown to depend crucially on whether one holds a direct or non-direct theory of perception. Only on the latter is this version plausible. An analysis of the second "semantic" version concludes that a materialist description and explanation of the world should not be expected to transparently convey all that would be of interest or importance to human beings. The final version explicitly makes use of Grover Maxwell's non-direct perceptual theory of structural realism. Although a confusion is charged to Maxwell between phenomenal and objective properties, the critical difficulty for the grain objection is its failure to characterize "structure" from a non-percipient point of view. As the grain objection is ultimately found wanting, the real difficulty for materialism crystallizes as its irreconciliability with the mere existence of sentience, which seems to force some sort of emergence upon us
|Keywords||No keywords specified (fix it)|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
References found in this work BETA
No references found.
Citations of this work BETA
The Case for Mental Duality: Evidence From Split-Brain Data and Other Considerations.Roland Puccetti - 1981 - Behavioral and Brain Sciences 4 (1):93-123.
Mental Ascriptions and Mental Unity: Molar Subjects, Brains, and Homunculi.Joseph Margolis - 1981 - Behavioral and Brain Sciences 4 (1):110.
Similar books and articles
The Strange New World in the Church: A Review Essay of "With the Grain of the Universe" by Stanley Hauerwas. [REVIEW]Brad J. Kallenberg - 2004 - Journal of Religious Ethics 32 (1):197 - 217.
Cultural Diversity and Civic Education: Two Versions of the Fragmentation Objection.Andrew Shorten - 2010 - Educational Philosophy and Theory 42 (1):57-72.
Reply to Nagasawa on the Inconsistency Objection to the Knowledge Argument.Neil Campbell - 2012 - Erkenntnis 76 (1):137-145.
The Illusions of Experience.Robert M. Anderson - 1974 - PSA: Proceedings of the Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association 1974:549 - 561.
Some Objections to Putnam's “Consistency Objection”.John A. Humphrey - 1993 - Journal of Philosophical Research 18:127-141.
Added to index2009-01-28
Total downloads10 ( #435,732 of 2,178,189 )
Recent downloads (6 months)1 ( #316,497 of 2,178,189 )
How can I increase my downloads?