Georgetown Journal of Legal Ethics 25 (1):107-164 (2012)
Even good lawyers get a bad rap. One explanation for this is that the professional rules governing lawyers permit and even require behavior that strikes many as immoral. The standard accounts of legal ethics that seek to defend these professional rules do little to dispel this air of immorality. The revisionary accounts of legal ethics that criticize the professional rules inject a hearty dose of morality, but at the cost of leaving lawyers unrecognizable as lawyers. This article suggests that the problem with both the professional rules and the extant accounts of legal ethics is that they treat the role of lawyer as largely uniform, whereas lawyers actually serve several importantly different roles in different contexts. The central insight of the article is that legal ethics must be fundamentally context-sensitive: what lawyers are morally permitted or required to do depends on the background context in which they are working. Additionally, by taking context into account, this article is the first to present a theory of legal ethics as appropriately shaped and constrained by normative political philosophy and norms of political legitimacy. Specifically, the article argues that people act as lawyers in three different contexts: State v. Individual (situations in which the State seeks to apply some general law to a particular individual), Individual v. Individual (situations in which private individuals are engaged in a dispute), and Individual v. State (situations in which individuals object to State conduct on constitutional or other grounds unrelated to the question of whether a general law applies to their particular case); that the value of lawyers, qua lawyers, stems from a different source in each of these contexts; and that a theory of legal ethics must take into account both of these first two claims. This article develops one such theory - the Multi-Context View. To demonstrate how the theory applies in practice, the article applies the Multi-Context View to two significant issues in legal ethics: the ethical issues involved in deciding whether to represent a client and the moral permissibility of the use of tactical delay.
|Keywords||legal ethics political philosophy political legitimacy professional ethics|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
References found in this work BETA
No references found.
Citations of this work BETA
No citations found.
Similar books and articles
Should Lawyers Listen to Philosophers About Legal Ethics?M. B. E. Smith - 1990 - Law and Philosophy 9 (1):67 - 93.
Legal Ethics and Regulatory Legitimacy : Regulating Lawyers for Personal Misconduct.Alice Woolley - 2011 - In Reid Mortensen, Francesca Bartlett & Kieran Tranter (eds.), Alternative Perspectives on Lawyers and Legal Ethics: Reimagining the Profession. Routledge.
The Role of Apologies in Professional Discipline.Francesca Bartlett - 2011 - Legal Ethics 14 (1):49-72.
Can They Do That? Legal Ethics in Popular Culture: Of Characters and Acts.Carrie Menkel-Meadow - manuscript -
Some Realism About Legal Realism for Lawyers: Assessing the Role of Context in Legal Ethics.David B. Wilkins - 2012 - In Leslie C. Levin & Lynn M. Mather (eds.), Lawyers in Practice: Ethical Decision Making in Context. University of Chicago Press. pp. 25.
Professional Legal Ethics: Critical Interrogations.Donald Nicolson & Julian Webb - 2000 - Oxford University Press.
Testing Times: In-House Counsel and Independence.Suzanne le Mire - 2011 - Legal Ethics 14 (1):21-47.
Business Regulation, Business Ethics and the Professional Employee.Karl J. Mackie - 1989 - Journal of Business Ethics 8 (8):607 - 616.
Lawyers' Business: Conflicts of Duties Arising From Lawyers' Business Models.Joanne Stagg-Taylor - 2011 - Legal Ethics 14 (2):173-192.
Legal Ethics and the Media: Are the Ethics of Lawyers and Journalists Irretrievably at Odds?Rachel Spencer - 2012 - Legal Ethics 15 (1):83-110.
Added to index2012-06-14
Total downloads56 ( #88,318 of 2,059,555 )
Recent downloads (6 months)9 ( #92,613 of 2,059,555 )
How can I increase my downloads?
There are no threads in this forum
Nothing in this forum yet.