Science in Context 4 (2):429-447 (1991)
AbstractThe ArgumentThis paper is concerned with “holism” as a German cultural “style” of doing psychobiology in Central Europe between the two world wars. The paper takes its starting point from a critical analysis of Forman's writings on nationalism versus internationalism in interwar German science, and the alleged “accommodation” of interwar German physics to an antiscientific, irrationalist culture. The paper argues that psychobiological holism was not just a reaction against nineteenth-century atomistic or mechanistic approaches to modeling life and mind; it also represented a domestically directed answer from within the German biomedical scientific community to broad religious and cultural “disenchantment.” As such, holistic psychobiology emerges as a phenomenon that challenges us with at least four levels of discourse: experimental/clinical, epistemological/philosophical, existential/religious, and ideological/political. The paper defends the methodological appropriateness of a collective case-study approach to the problem of holism as a multilevel discourse. It concludes by offering a preliminary contextualized analysis of the thought of three representative holistic leaders of the time: behavioral biologist and ethologist Jakob von Uexküll; clinical neurologist Constantin von Monakow; and neuropsychiatrist Kurt Goldstein.
Similar books and articles
Marshal pétain and french nationalism: The interwar years and vichy.Jacques Szaluta - 1992 - History of European Ideas 15 (1-3):113-118.
Changing conception of nationalism in hodza, Milan writings before world-war-I and during the interwar period+ slovak philosophy 1900-1940.K. Kollar - 1995 - Filozofia 50 (12):713-728.
The psychobiology of sexual experience.Julian M. Davidson - 1980 - In J. M. Davidson & Richard J. Davidson (eds.), The Psychobiology of Consciousness. Plenum. pp. 271--332.
Toward a liberal socialist cosmopolitan nationalism.Kai Nielsen - 2003 - International Journal of Philosophical Studies 11 (4):437 – 463.
Rethinking Historical Materialism: The New Edition of "The German Ideology".Wei Xiaoping - 2010 - Science and Society 74 (4):489 - 508.
Tragic thought: Romantic nationalism in the german tradition.Patricia Anne Simpson - 1993 - History of European Ideas 16 (1-3):331-336.
In Defense of Nationalism with Reference to Canada and the Baltics.Cornelius Kampe - 2000 - Social Philosophy Today 16:47-56.
A new beginning? German medical and political traditions in the aftermath of the second world war.Jessica Reinisch - 2007 - Minerva 45 (3):241-257.
On German Nationalism: Reply to Geulen.M. Mueller - 1995 - Telos: Critical Theory of the Contemporary 1995 (105):21-42.
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads
Citations of this work
Language and Human Nature. Kurt Goldstein's Neurolinguistic Foundation of a Holistic Philosophy.David Ludwig - 2012 - Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences 48 (1):40-54.
Review Essay Scientific Styles: Toward Some Common Ground in the History, Philosophy, and Sociology of Science.Marga Vicedo - 1995 - Perspectives on Science 3 (2):231-254.
Factors Shaping Ernst Mayr's Concepts in the History of Biology.Thomas Junker - 1996 - Journal of the History of Biology 29 (1):29 - 77.
The construction of colorimetry by committee.Sean F. Johnston - 1996 - Science in Context 9 (4):387-420.
The Construction of Colorimetry by Committee.Sean F. Johnston - 1996 - Science in Context 9 (4):387-420.
References found in this work
The Organism: A Holistic Approach to Biology Derived from Pathological Data in Man.Kurt Goldstein - 1995
Weimar culture, causality, and quantum theory, 1918-1927: Adaptation by German physicists and mathematicians to a hostile intellectual environment. [REVIEW]Paul Forman - 1971 - Historical Studies in the Physical Sciences 3 (1).
Scientific Internationalism and the Weimar Physicists: The Ideology and Its Manipulation in Germany after World War I.Paul Forman - 1973 - Isis 64:150-180.
The earliest missionaries of the Copenhagen spirit.John L. Heilbron - 1985 - Revue d'Histoire des Sciences 38 (3-4):195-230.
The Decline of the West: Form and Actuality.Oswald Spengler & Charles Francis Atkinson - 1932 - G. Allen & Unwin.