On Identity Statements: In Defense of a Sui Generis View

Disputatio 8 (43):269-293 (2016)
  Copy   BIBTEX

Abstract

This paper is about the meaning and function of identity statements involving proper names. There are two prominent views on this topic, according to which identity statements ascribe a relation: the object-view, on which identity statements ascribe a relation borne by all objects to themselves, and the name-view, on which an identity statement 'a is b' says that the names 'a' and 'b' codesignate. The object- and name-views may seem to exhaust the field. I make a case for treating identity statements as sui generis instead of attempting to explain them by means of the idea that they ascribe a relation. My contention is that once we do this, no analysis is required. I do not wish to insist that we stop saying that identity statements ascribe a relation. The point is that there is a fundamental disanalogy between identity statements and other two-termed statements which we overlook to our peril. This will be seen to parallel the more recognized disanalogy between existence statements and other one-termed statements. One way of registering the fundamental disanalogy is to say that identity statements are not relational, but this is not essential. Following my negative arguments in section 2, I employ some simple diagrammatical models in section 3 to exhibit the fundamental disanalogy. In a final section I respond to some possible objections which may be raised against this kind of approach.

Similar books and articles

Identity statements and microreductions.Berent Enç - 1976 - Journal of Philosophy 73 (June):285-306.
Number words and reference to numbers.Katharina Felka - 2014 - Philosophical Studies 168 (1):261-282.
La noción de identidad en los "Tópicos".Mario Mignucci - 2002 - Anuario Filosófico 35 (73):313-340.
Kripke's Fregean Argument Against Materialism.Paul Inman Coppock - 1982 - Dissertation, Princeton University
Reconstruing Modal Intuitions.Janet Levin - 2011 - Croatian Journal of Philosophy 11 (1):97-112.

Analytics

Added to PP
2016-06-21

Downloads
868 (#16,194)

6 months
119 (#29,897)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author's Profile

Tristan Grøtvedt Haze
University of Melbourne

Citations of this work

What is Identical?Marta Vlasáková - 2021 - Logica Universalis 15 (2):153-170.
Necessity and Propositions.Tristan Haze - 2017 - Dissertation, University of Sydney
Schmidentity and informativity.Hannes Fraissler - 2020 - Synthese 198 (10):9963-9989.

Add more citations

References found in this work

Philosophical Investigations.Ludwig Wittgenstein - 1953 - New York, NY, USA: Wiley-Blackwell. Edited by G. E. M. Anscombe.
Word and Object.Willard Van Orman Quine - 1960 - Cambridge, MA, USA: MIT Press.
Meaning and Necessity: A Study in Semantics and Modal Logic.Rudolf Carnap - 1947 - Chicago, IL, USA: University of Chicago Press.
Frege’s Puzzle (2nd edition).Nathan U. Salmon - 1986 - Atascadero, CA: Ridgeview Publishing Company.

View all 63 references / Add more references