Nursing Ethics 25 (1):92-110 (2018)
AbstractBackground:To better understand the kinds of ethical challenges that emerge when using coercion in mental healthcare, and the importance of these ethical challenges, this article presents a systematic review of scientific literature.Methods:A systematic search in the databases MEDLINE, PsychInfo, Cinahl, Sociologicals and Web of Knowledge was carried out. The search terms derived from the population, intervention, comparison/setting and outcome. A total of 22 studies were included.Ethical considerations:The review is conducted according to the Vancouver Protocol.Results:There are few studies that study ethical challenges when using coercion in an explicit way. However, promoting the patient’s best interest is the most important justification for coercion. Patient autonomy is a fundamental challenge facing any use of coercion, and some kind of autonomy infringement is a key aspect of the concept of coercion. The concepts of coercion and autonomy and the relations between them are very complex. When coercion is used, a primary ethical challenge is to assess the balance between promoting good and inflicting harm. In the included studies, findings explicitly related to justice are few. Some studies focus on moral distress experienced by the healthcare professionals using coercion.Conclusion:There is a lack of literature explicitly addressing ethical challenges related to the use of coercion in mental healthcare. It is essential for healthcare personnel to develop a strong awareness of which ethical challenges they face in connection with the use of coercion, as well as challenges related to justice. How to address ethical challenges in ways that prevent illegitimate paternalism and strengthen beneficent treatment and care and trust in connection with the use of coercion is a ‘clinical must’. By developing a more refined and rich language describing ethical challenges, clinicians may be better equipped to prevent coercion and the accompanying moral distress.
Similar books and articles
Ethical challenges in connection with the use of coercion: a focus group study of health care personnel in mental health care.Marit H. Hem, Bert Molewijk & Reidar Pedersen - 2014 - BMC Medical Ethics 15 (1):82.
Dealing with ethical challenges: a focus group study with professionals in mental health care.Bert Molewijk, Marit Helene Hem & Reidar Pedersen - 2015 - BMC Medical Ethics 16 (1):4.
The Role of Ethics in Reducing and Improving the Quality of Coercion in Mental Health Care.Reidun Norvoll, Marit Helene Hem & Reidar Pedersen - 2017 - HEC Forum 29 (1):59-74.
Patients’ moral views on coercion in mental healthcare.Reidun Norvoll & Reidar Pedersen - forthcoming - Nursing Ethics:096973301667476.
How to avoid and prevent coercion in nursing homes.Elisabeth Gjerberg, Marit Helene Hem, Reidun Førde & Reidar Pedersen - 2013 - Nursing Ethics 20 (6):632-644.
Coercion in the Community: A Situated Approach to the Examination of Ethical Challenges for Mental Health Social Workers.Jim Campbell & Gavin Davidson - 2009 - Ethics and Social Welfare 3 (3):249-263.
Staff’s normative attitudes towards coercion: the role of moral doubt and professional context—a cross-sectional survey study.Almar Kok Bert Molewijk, Reidar Pedersen Tonje Husum & Olaf Aasland - forthcoming - Most Recent Articles: Bmc Medical Ethics.
Two years of moral case deliberations on the use of coercion in mental health care: Which ethical challenges are being discussed by health care professionals?Bert Molewijk, Ingvild Stokke Engerdahl & Reidar Pedersen - 2016 - Clinical Ethics 11 (2-3):87-96.
Staff’s normative attitudes towards coercion: the role of moral doubt and professional context—a cross-sectional survey study.Bert Molewijk, Almar Kok, Tonje Husum, Reidar Pedersen & Olaf Aasland - 2017 - BMC Medical Ethics 18 (1):37.
Four Reasons Why Assisted Dying Should Not Be Offered for Depression.Thomas Blikshavn, Tonje Lossius Husum & Morten Magelssen - 2017 - Journal of Bioethical Inquiry 14 (1):151-157.
Coercion and pressure in psychiatry: lessons from Ulysses.G. Widdershoven & R. Berghmans - 2007 - Journal of Medical Ethics 33 (10):560-563.
Coercion in nursing homes.Elisabeth Gjerberg, Lillian Lillemoen, Reidar Pedersen & Reidun Førde - 2016 - Nursing Ethics 23 (3):253-264.
Informal Coercion in the Physical Care of Patients Suffering from Senile Dementia or Mental Retardation.T. Tännsjö - 1999 - Nursing Ethics 6 (4):327-336.
Dealing with ethical problems in the healthcare system in Lithuania: achievements and challenges.V. Bankauskaite - 2006 - Journal of Medical Ethics 32 (10):584-587.
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads
Citations of this work
The significance of ethics reflection groups in mental health care: a focus group study among health care professionals.Marit Helene Hem, Bert Molewijk, Elisabeth Gjerberg, Lillian Lillemoen & Reidar Pedersen - 2018 - BMC Medical Ethics 19 (1):54.
Defining ethical challenge(s) in healthcare research: a rapid review.Richard Huxtable, Lucy Ellen Selman, Mariana Dittborn & Guy Schofield - 2021 - BMC Medical Ethics 22 (1):1-17.
Ethics in nursing: A systematic review of the framework of evidence perspective.Erman Yıldız - 2019 - Nursing Ethics 26 (4):1128-1148.
Ethical challenges in home-based care: A systematic literature review.Anne Kari Tolo Heggestad, Morten Magelssen, Reidar Pedersen & Elisabeth Gjerberg - forthcoming - Nursing Ethics:096973302096885.
Gilles Deleuze's societies of control: Implications for mental health nursing and coercive community care.Etienne Paradis-Gagné & Dave Holmes - 2022 - Nursing Philosophy 23 (2).
References found in this work
Principles of Biomedical Ethics.Ezekiel J. Emanuel, Tom L. Beauchamp & James F. Childress - 1995 - Hastings Center Report 25 (4):37.
Implementing moral case deliberation in a psychiatric hospital: process and outcome. [REVIEW]Bert Molewijk, Maarten Verkerk, Henk Milius & Guy Widdershoven - 2008 - Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 11 (1):43-56.
Evaluating clinical ethics support in mental healthcare: A systematic literature review.M. H. Hem, R. Pedersen, R. Norvoll & B. Molewijk - 2015 - Nursing Ethics 22 (4):452-466.
Ethical challenges and how to develop ethics support in primary health care.Lillian Lillemoen & Reidar Pedersen - 2013 - Nursing Ethics 20 (1):96-108.
Conceptions of Care: Altruism, Feminism, and Mature Care.Tove Pettersen - 2012 - Hypatia 27 (2):366-389.