Behavioral and Brain Sciences 21 (1):101-114 (1998)

Since the BBS article in which Premack and Woodruff (1978) asked “Does the chimpanzee have a theory of mind?,” it has been repeatedly claimed that there is observational and experimental evidence that apes have mental state concepts, such as “want” and “know.” Unlike research on the development of theory of mind in childhood, however, no substantial progress has been made through this work with nonhuman primates. A survey of empirical studies of imitation, self-recognition, social relationships, deception, role-taking, and perspective-taking suggests that in every case where nonhuman primate behavior has been interpreted as a sign of theory of mind, it could instead have occurred by chance or as a product of nonmentalistic processes such as associative learning or inferences based on nonmental categories. Arguments to the effect that, in spite of this, the theory of mind hypothesis should be accepted because it is more parsimonious than alternatives or because it is supported by convergent evidence are not compelling. Such arguments are based on unsupportable assumptions about the role of parsimony in science and either ignore the requirement that convergent evidence proceed from independent assumptions, or fail to show that it supports the theory of mind hypothesis over nonmentalist alternatives. Progress in research on theory of mind requires experimental procedures that can distinguish the theory of mind hypothesis from nonmentalist alternatives. A procedure that may have this potential is proposed. It uses conditional discrimination training and transfer tests to determine whether chimpanzees have the concept “see.” Commentators are invited to identify flaws in the procedure and to suggest alternatives. Key Words: apes; associative learning; concepts; convergence; deception; evolution of intelligence; folk psychology; imitation; mental state attribution; monkeys; parsimony; perspective-taking; primates; role-taking; self-recognition; social cognition; social intelligence; theory of mind.
Keywords apes   associative learning   concepts   convergence   deception   evolution of intelligence   folk psychology   imitation   mental state attribution   monkeys   parsimony
Categories (categorize this paper)
DOI 10.1017/s0140525x98000703
Edit this record
Mark as duplicate
Export citation
Find it on Scholar
Request removal from index
Revision history

Download options

PhilArchive copy

Upload a copy of this paper     Check publisher's policy     Papers currently archived: 63,326
Through your library

References found in this work BETA

Does the Chimpanzee Have a Theory of Mind?David Premack & G. Woodruff - 1978 - Behavioral and Brain Sciences 4 (4):515-629.
Does the Chimpanzee Have a Theory of Mind?David Premack & Guy Woodruff - 1978 - Behavioral and Brain Sciences 1 (4):515-526.

Add more references

Citations of this work BETA

The 'Shared Manifold' Hypothesis: From Mirror Neurons to Empathy.Vittorio Gallese - 2001 - Journal of Consciousness Studies 8 (5-7):33-50.
The Cognitive Functions of Language.Peter Carruthers - 2002 - Behavioral and Brain Sciences 25 (6):657-674.

View all 109 citations / Add more citations

Similar books and articles

More Theory and Evolution, Please!Radu J. Bogdan - 2001 - Behavioral and Brain Sciences 24 (6):1140-1141.
Theory of Mind in Nonhuman Primates: A Question of Language?Colin Gray & Phil Russell - 1998 - Behavioral and Brain Sciences 21 (1):121-121.
What Can We Learn From the Absence of Evidence?Thomas R. Zentall - 1998 - Behavioral and Brain Sciences 21 (1):133-134.
Liberalism, Chauvinism, and Experimental Thought.C. M. Heyes - 1998 - Behavioral and Brain Sciences 21 (1):134-148.
The Prior Question: Do Human Primates Have a Theory of Mind?Robert M. Gordon - 1998 - Behavioral and Brain Sciences 21 (1):120-121.
Theory of Mind and Other Domain-Specific Hypotheses.C. M. Heyes - 2001 - Behavioral and Brain Sciences 24 (6):1143-1145.
More Theory and Evolution.Radu Bogdan - 1991 - Behavioral and Brain Sciences 18 (1):390-391.


Added to PP index

Total views
135 ( #78,659 of 2,448,737 )

Recent downloads (6 months)
4 ( #177,863 of 2,448,737 )

How can I increase my downloads?


My notes