Behavioral and Brain Sciences 42:1-40 (2019)
AbstractMicrobiota-gut-brain research is a fast-growing field of inquiry with important implications for how human brain function and behaviour are understood. Researchers manipulate gut microbes to reveal connections between intestinal microbiota and normal brain functions or pathological states. Many claims are made about causal relationships between gut microbiota and human behaviour. By uncovering these relationships, MGB research aims to offer new explanations of mental health and potential avenues of treatment. So far, limited evaluation has been made of MGB's methods and its core experimental findings, many of which are extensively reiterated in copious reviews of the field. These factors, plus the self-help potential of MGB, have combined to encourage uncritical public uptake of MGB discoveries. Both social and professional media focus on the potential for dietary intervention in mental health, and causal relationships are assumed to be established. Our target article has two main aims. One is to examine critically the core practices and findings of experimental MGB research and to raise questions about them for brain and behavioural scientists who may not be familiar with the field. The other is to challenge the way in which MGB findings are presented. Our positive goal is to suggest how current problems and weaknesses may be addressed, in order for both scientific and public audiences to gain a clearer picture of MGB research and its strengths and limitations.
Similar books and articles
Gutsy Moves: The Amygdala as a Critical Node in Microbiota to Brain Signaling.Caitlin S. M. Cowan, Alan E. Hoban, Ana Paula Ventura-Silva, Timothy G. Dinan, Gerard Clarke & John F. Cryan - 2018 - Bioessays 40 (1):1700172.
Functional Classification of the Gut Microbiota: The Key to Cracking the Microbiota Composition Code.Connor E. Rosen & Noah W. Palm - 2017 - Bioessays 39 (12):1700032.
It Takes Guts to Grow a Brain.Betty Diamond, Patricio T. Huerta, Kevin Tracey & Bruce T. Volpe - 2011 - Bioessays 33 (8):588-591.
Biobanking for Human Microbiome Research: Promise, Risks, and Ethics.Yonghui Ma, Hua Chen, Ruipeng Lei & Jianlin Ren - 2017 - Asian Bioethics Review 9 (4):311-324.
The Ethos of Critical Research and the Idea of a Coming Research Community.J. Masschelein M. Simons - 2005 - Educational Philosophy and Theory 37 (6):817-832.
Natural World Physical, Brain Operational, and Mind Phenomenal Space-Time.Andrew A. Fingelkurts, Alexander A. Fingelkurts & Carlos F. H. Neves - 2010 - Physics of Life Reviews 7 (2):195-249.
Complementing a Positivist Approach to Investment Analysis with Critical Realism : Challenges and a Way Forward.Loretta O'Donnell, Robin Kramar & Maria Dyball - unknown
The Role of Psychology in Functional Localization Research.Barbara V. E. Klein - 1978 - PSA: Proceedings of the Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association 1978:119 - 133.
Can the Self Be a Brain?Alan Kenneth Schwerin - 2015 - Principia: An International Journal of Epistemology 19 (2): 235 - 246.
Combining Brain and Behavioral Data to Improve Econometric Policy Analysis.Daniel Houser, Daniel Schunk & Erte Xiao - 2007 - Analyse & Kritik 29 (1):86-96.
The Microbiota‐Inflammasome Hypothesis of Major Depression.Antonio Inserra, Geraint B. Rogers, Julio Licinio & Ma‐Li Wong - 2018 - Bioessays 40 (9):1800027.
Wie kritisch ist die Kritische Diskursanalyse? Ansätze zu einer Wende kritischer Wissenschaft. [How critical is Critical Discourse Analysis? Approaches to a turn in critical research].Veronika Koller - 2009 - Critical Discourse Studies 6 (4):323-325.
Diet Dominates Host Genotype in Shaping the Murine Gut Microbiota.R. N. Carmody, G. K. Gerber, J. M. Luevano, D. M. Gatti, L. Somes, K. L. Svenson & P. J. Turnbaugh - unknown
Mental Causation Via Neuroprosthetics? A Critical Analysis.Tuomas Pernu - 2018 - Synthese (12):5159-5174.
Research Proposal for the Application of Critical Discourse Analysis to the Study of Learning Cultures.Luca Magni - 2011 - Journal of Critical Realism 10 (4):527-542.
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads
Citations of this work
Out of Our Skull, in Our Skin: The Microbiota-Gut-Brain Axis and the Extended Cognition Thesis.Federico Boem, Gabriele Ferretti & Silvano Zipoli Caiani - 2021 - Biology and Philosophy 36 (2):1-32.
Are Emotional States Based in the Brain? A Critique of Affective Brainocentrism From a Physiological Perspective.Giovanna Colombetti & Eder Zavala - 2019 - Biology and Philosophy 34 (5):45.
Microbiome Causality: Further Reflections.Kate E. Lynch, Emily C. Parke & Maureen A. O’Malley - 2020 - Biology and Philosophy 35 (2):1-16.
Microbiome in Precision Psychiatry: An Overview of the Ethical Challenges Regarding Microbiome Big Data and Microbiome-Based Interventions.Eman Ahmed & Kristien Hens - 2022 - American Journal of Bioethics Neuroscience 13 (4):270-286.
References found in this work
No references found.