Philosophy and Public Affairs 46 (2):160-174 (2018)
AbstractIs there any number of people you should save from paralysis rather than saving one person from death? Is there any number of people you should save from a headache rather than saving one person from death? Many people answer ‘yes’ and ‘no’, respectively. They therefore accept a partially aggregative moral view. Patrick Tomlin has recently argued that the most promising partially aggregative views in the literature have implausible implications in certain cases in which there are additions or subtractions to the groups of people that we can save. Several philosophers have begun responding to this argument by developing partially aggregative views that avoid the relevant implications. In this paper, I extend Tomlin’s argument to create a dilemma that no partially aggregative view can avoid. I conclude that we should accept a fully aggregative moral view.
Similar books and articles
When, If Ever, Do We Aggregate? And Why?: Jan Narveson.Jan Narveson - 2009 - Social Philosophy and Policy 26 (1):48-75.
Aggregate Democracy and Deliberative Democracy: An Inevitable Practical Circle.Macarena Marey - 2011 - Ideas Y Valores 60 (147):153-175.
Lose Balance in Total Amount of Supply and Demand and Changing of the Economic Growth Pattern-Immediate Effects in Blazing New Trails in Institution.Guang-hua Zhu & Wen-bin Duan - 1997 - Nankai University (Philosophy and Social Sciences) 4:57-61.
On the Transcendental Philosophy in the Light of the Kantian Aggregate–System Opposition.Przemysław Parszutowicz - 2013 - Archiwum Historii Filozofii I Myśli Społecznej 58.
The Phenomenon of Aggregate Recoil: The Premature Acceptance of an Essentially Incorrect Theory.Thaddeus J. Trenn - 1980 - Annals of Science 37 (1):81-100.
Homunculi Are People Too! Lewis's Definition of Personhood Debugged.Cody Gilmore - 2017 - Thought: A Journal of Philosophy 6 (1):54-60.
Aggregate Theory: An Integrated Approach to Business Ethics.Ernest Edwin Edmundson - 1998 - Dissertation, Tulane University
Globalization: Meaning and Measurement.Charles Wolf - 2000 - Critical Review: A Journal of Politics and Society 14 (1):1-10.
Aggregate Rationality in Adjudication and Legislation.Lewis A. Kornhauser - 2008 - Politics, Philosophy and Economics 7 (1):5-27.
Presupposition, Aggregation, and Leibniz’s Argument for a Plurality of Substances.Richard T. W. Arthur - 2011 - The Leibniz Review 21:91-115.
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads
Citations of this work
Aggregation, Balancing, and Respect for the Claims of Individuals.Bastian Steuwer - 2021 - Utilitas 33 (1):17-34.
Relevance Rides Again? Aggregation and Local Relevance.Aart van Gils & Patrick Tomlin - 2020 - In David Sobel, Peter Vallentyne & Steven Wall (eds.), Oxford Studies in Political Philosophy. Oxford Studies in Political Philosophy Series, 6. Oxford University Press.
The Rat Race and Working Time Regulation.Malte Jauch - 2020 - Politics, Philosophy and Economics 19 (3):293-314.
References found in this work
No references found.