On the nature and norms of theoretical commitment

Philosophy of Science 58 (1):1-14 (1991)
  Copy   BIBTEX

Abstract

It is not uncommon for philosophers to maintain that one is obliged to believe nothing beyond the observable consequences of a successful scientific theory. This doctrine is variously known as instrumentalism, fictionalism, constructive empiricism, theoretical skepticism and the philosophy of "as if". The purpose of the present paper is to subject such forms of scientific antirealism to a two-pronged critique. In the first place it is argued that there is no genuine difference between believing a theory and being disposed to use it to make predictions, design experiments, and so on; so traditional instrumentalism is incoherent. In the second place, a retrenched position is considered in which theoretical belief would be tolerated but said to be justified on merely pragmatic, and not epistemic, grounds. In criticizing this point of view it is shown that the onus of proof rests on anyone who maintains it; furthermore, the only possible rationale for it (which is based on underdetermination of theory by data) is described, and various deficiencies in this argument are exposed.

Links

PhilArchive



    Upload a copy of this work     Papers currently archived: 94,517

External links

Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server

Through your library

Similar books and articles

Agnostic empiricism versus scientific realism: Belief in truth matters.Stathis Psillos - 2000 - International Studies in the Philosophy of Science 14 (1):57 – 75.
Scientific Realism and Components.Marc Lange - 1994 - The Monist 77 (1):111-127.
Underdetermination and Scientific Realism.Jalal Abdollahi & Javad Akbari Takhtameshlou - 2021 - Philosophical Investigations 15 (34):224-247.
Down to Earth Underdetermination.Gordon Belot - 2015 - Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 91 (2):456-464.
Studies in scientific realism.Stathis Psillos - 2001 - Foundations of Chemistry 3 (1):79-86.
On the coherence of instrumentalism.Andre Kukla - 1992 - Philosophy of Science 59 (3):492-497.

Analytics

Added to PP
2009-01-28

Downloads
143 (#132,081)

6 months
22 (#158,932)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author's Profile

Paul Horwich
New York University

Citations of this work

Structural Realism.James Ladyman - 2014 - In Edward N. Zalta (ed.), The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Stanford, CA: The Metaphysics Research Lab.
Fictionalism.Matti Eklund - 2010 - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
Fictionalism.Arthur Fine - 1993 - Midwest Studies in Philosophy 18 (1):1-18.

View all 34 citations / Add more citations

References found in this work

Science without numbers, A Defence of Nominalism.Hartry Field - 1980 - Revue Philosophique de la France Et de l'Etranger 171 (4):502-503.
Mind and Meaning.Brian Loar - 1985 - Philosophy of Science 52 (1):157-159.
Three forms of realism.Paul Horwich - 1982 - Synthese 51 (2):181 - 201.

Add more references