Making Fair Comparisons in Political Theory

American Journal of Political Science (forthcoming)
  Copy   BIBTEX


Normative political theorists frequently compare hypothetical scenarios for the purpose of identifying reasons to prefer one kind of institution to alternatives. We examine three types of "unfair" comparisons and the reasoning errors associated with each. A theorist makes an _obscure comparison_ when one (or more) of the alternatives under consideration is underspecified; a theorist makes a _mismatched comparison_ when they fail to hold fixed the relevant contextual factors while comparing alternatives; and a theorist makes an _irrelevant comparison_ when they compare alternatives assuming contextual factors that differ in important respects from those they "should" assume given their theoretical aims. We then introduce the notion of a modeling mindset and show how this mindset can help theorists detect and avoid the three types of error. We conclude with a reconstruction of Cohen's (2009) camping trip thought experiment to illustrate the approach.



External links

Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server

Through your library

Similar books and articles

In Defence of My Favourite Theory.Johan E. Gustafsson & Olle Torpman - 2014 - Pacific Philosophical Quarterly 95 (2):159-174.
Interpersonal Comparisons of Well-Being.Jon Elster & John E. Roemer (eds.) - 1991 - New York: Cambridge University Press.
Interpersonal comparisons of well-being.Jon Elster & John E. Roemer (eds.) - 1991 - New York: Cambridge University Press.
Interpersonal comparisons with preferences and desires.Jacob Barrett - 2019 - Politics, Philosophy and Economics 18 (3):219-241.
The Nature of Model-World Comparisons.Fiora Salis - 2016 - The Monist 99 (3):243-259.
Modeling Interpretation and the Practice of Political Theory.Martin Beckstein & Ralph Weber - 2021 - New York: Routledge. Edited by Ralph E. Weber.
Making Interpersonal Comparisons Coherently.Martin Barrett & Daniel Hausman - 1990 - Economics and Philosophy 6 (2):293.
An Analysis of the Fair Play Theory of Political Obligation.Sivakumar Elambooranan - 1997 - Dissertation, University of California, Santa Barbara
Vague Comparisons.Cristian Constantinescu - 2016 - Ratio 29 (4):357-377.
Extended Preferences and Interpersonal Comparisons of Well‐being.Hilary Greaves & Harvey Lederman - 2016 - Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 96 (3):636-667.
Aggregation Without Interpersonal Comparisons of Well‐Being.Jacob M. Nebel - 2022 - Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 105 (1):18-41.


Added to PP

200 (#95,593)

6 months
200 (#12,327)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author Profiles

Sean Ingham
University of California, San Diego
David Wiens
University of California, San Diego

Citations of this work

No citations found.

Add more citations

References found in this work

Justice as fairness: a restatement.John Rawls (ed.) - 2001 - Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.
Against Democracy: New Preface.Jason Brennan - 2016 - Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Ideal and nonideal theory.A. John Simmons - 2010 - Philosophy and Public Affairs 38 (1):5-36.

View all 18 references / Add more references