‘A Perfect Contradiction is Mysterious for the Clever and for Fools Alike’: Did Hegel Contradict Aristotle?

Hegel Bulletin 41 (1):1-18 (2020)
  Copy   BIBTEX


Aristotle argued that there are no true statements of the form. In his lectures on history of philosophy Hegel does not challenge this view and in his Science of Logic expresses admiration for Aristotle's rebuttal of Zeno of Elea's attempt to find such contradictions in his paradoxes of motion. Yet more than once in his logics Hegel insists that everything is contradictory. I approach this problem from two directions. First, Widerspruch often means, and is understood by Hegel to mean, ‘opposition’ rather than ‘contradiction’ in the strict logical sense. Thus Catullus's simultaneous love and hatred of Clodia is a contradiction, but not an Aristotelian, or formal logical, contradiction. I defuse Hegel's occasional suggestions of Aristotelian contradictions in motion and time. Second, I exploit Hegel's tacit rejection of Aristotle's official bivalence account of truth and falsity, in favour of the view that truth is approached by successive improvements in our inevitably imperfect attempts to attain it. In this respect Hegel's procedure is similar to that of Aristotle himself, who characteristically constructs his own view of metaphysics, physics, ethics, etc., from the imperfect, but not flatly false, opinions of his predecessors. ‘The truth is the whole’, that is, the whole sequence of our attempts to reach it.



    Upload a copy of this work     Papers currently archived: 89,654

External links

Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server

Through your library

Similar books and articles

Hegel and Aristotle.Alfredo Ferrarin - 2001 - New York: Cambridge University Press.
On Hegel's Doctrine of Contradiction.Michael Wolff - 1999 - The Owl of Minerva 31 (1):1-22.
Hegel's account of contradiction in the science of logic reconsidered.Karin de Boer - 2010 - Journal of the History of Philosophy 48 (3):345-373.
Hegel, contradicción Y dialetheia.Rafael Miranda Rojas - 2013 - Revista de filosofía (Chile) 69:169-181.
Hegel's Reception of Aristotle's Theology.Tobias Dangel - 2020 - Hegel Bulletin 41 (1):102-117.
Contradiction or non-contradiction? Hegel's dialectic between Brandom and Priest.Michela Bordignon - 2012 - Verifiche: Rivista Trimestrale di Scienze Umane 41 (1-3).
Hegelian Identity.Ioannis Trisokkas - 2016 - Journal of the British Society for Phenomenology 47 (2):98-116.
Aristotle, Protagoras, and Contradiction: Metaphysics Γ 4-6.Evan Keeling - 2013 - Journal of Ancient Philosophy 7 (2):75-99.


Added to PP

22 (#599,880)

6 months
3 (#433,312)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author's Profile

Citations of this work

Michael Inwood (1944–2021).Robert Stern - 2023 - Hegel Bulletin 44 (1):1-4.

Add more citations

References found in this work

The unreality of time.John Ellis McTaggart - 1908 - Mind 17 (68):457-474.
An Essay Concerning Human Understanding.John Locke - 1979 - Revue Philosophique de la France Et de l'Etranger 169 (2):221-222.
Hegel: A Biography.Terry Pinkard - 2000 - Tijdschrift Voor Filosofie 63 (2):414-416.
The endoxon Mystique: What endoxa are and What They are Not.Dorothea Frede - 2012 - Oxford Studies in Ancient Philosophy 43:185-215.

View all 9 references / Add more references