Philosophia Mathematica 9 (3):308--330 (2001)

According to realist structuralism, mathematical objects are places in abstract structures. We argue that in spite of its many attractions, realist structuralism must be rejected. For, first, mathematical structures typically contain intra-structurally indiscernible places. Second, any account of place-identity available to the realist structuralist entails that intra-structurally indiscernible places are identical. Since for her mathematical singular terms denote places in structures, she would have to say, for example, that 1 = − 1 in the group (Z, +). We call this the identity problem and conclude that nominalism is presently the safest route for the structuralist
Keywords structuralism   identity   mathematics   WAYS
Categories (categorize this paper)
DOI 10.1093/philmat/9.3.308
Edit this record
Mark as duplicate
Export citation
Find it on Scholar
Request removal from index
Revision history

Download options

PhilArchive copy

Upload a copy of this paper     Check publisher's policy     Papers currently archived: 62,481
Through your library

References found in this work BETA

The Philosophy of Mathematics.W. D. Hart (ed.) - 1996 - Oxford University Press.
The Metaphysics of Abstract Objects.E. J. Lowe - 1995 - Journal of Philosophy 92 (10):509-524.

View all 9 references / Add more references

Citations of this work BETA

What Are Structural Properties?†.Johannes Korbmacher & Georg Schiemer - 2018 - Philosophia Mathematica 26 (3):295-323.
Criteria of Identity and Structuralist Ontology.Hannes Leitgeb & James Ladyman - 2008 - Philosophia Mathematica 16 (3):388-396.
Structuralism and the Notion of Dependence.Øystein Linnebo - 2008 - Philosophical Quarterly 58 (230):59-79.

View all 62 citations / Add more citations

Similar books and articles

The Identity Problem for Realist Structuralism II : A Reply to Shapiro.Jukka Keränen - 2006 - In Fraser MacBride (ed.), Identity and Modality. Oxford University Press. pp. 146--163.
On Structuralism’s Multiple Paths Through Spacetime Theories.Edward Slowik - 2012 - European Journal for Philosophy of Science 2 (1):45-66.
Instantiation is Not Partial Identity.Nicholas Mantegani - 2013 - Philosophical Studies 163 (3):697-715.
Representation: The Problem for Structuralism.Bas C. van Fraassen - 2006 - Philosophy of Science 73 (5):536-547.
Does the Non-Identity Problem Block a Class of Arguments Against Cloning?Richard Greene - 2004 - International Journal of Applied Philosophy 18 (1):95-101.
Structure and Identity.Stewart Shapiro - 2006 - In Fraser MacBride (ed.), Identity and Modality. Oxford University Press. pp. 34--69.


Added to PP index

Total views
241 ( #39,989 of 2,446,293 )

Recent downloads (6 months)
12 ( #55,904 of 2,446,293 )

How can I increase my downloads?


My notes