Hypatia 27 (1):99-117 (2012)
Prompted by the ever-increasing cesarean rate, this paper considers the interpretive disjunct between two significant strands of feminist analysis that have arisen in the last four decades as a consequence of the phenomenon of medicalized birth. In contrast to the dominant paradigm of bioethical “Principalism,” both modes of analysis, understood as “the critique of industrialized labor” and “the critique of idealized labor,” are attentive to the way in which social discourses inform bioethical deliberation and practice, but significantly diverge in the nature of their accounts. The “industrialization critique” understands the culture of medical intervention to be impelled by an “obstetric desire” to appropriate women's reproductive potency, whereas the “idealization critique” relates new mothers’ “low childbirth satisfaction” to a pernicious normative ideal propagated by the natural childbirth movement. This paper will explore the anatomy of both critiques and interrogate their fidelity to the phenomenological insight of the body as chiasm between material and ideal. I will argue that while the insights of the idealization critique are well grounded, we must exercise caution about the critique's tendency to reductively understand the embodied experience of labor as entirely discursively produced, a gesture that risks re-performing the dematerialization of women often effected through obstetric intervention itself
|Keywords||No keywords specified (fix it)|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
References found in this work BETA
Pregnant Embodiment: Subjectivity and Alienation.Iris Marion Young - 1984 - Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 9 (1):45-62.
Citations of this work BETA
No citations found.
Similar books and articles
A Value-Theoretic Approach to Childbirth and Reproductive Engineering.Kathryn Russell - 1994 - Science and Society 58 (3):287 - 314.
Value, Capital and Nature: Some Ecological Implications of Marx's Critique of Political Economy.Paul Burkett - 1996 - Science and Society 60 (3):332 - 359.
Feminist Bioethics and Psychiatry.Norah Martin - 2001 - Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 26 (4):431 – 441.
The End or the Apotheosis of "Labor"? Hannah Arendts Contribution to the Question of the Good Life in Times of Global Superfluity of Human Labor Power.Claudia Lenz & Gertrudetr Postl - 2005 - Hypatia 20 (2):135-154.
On Replacing Labor as the Substance of Value: Early and Recent Arguments.Cheol-Soo Park - 2003 - Science and Society 67 (2):160 - 172.
Rough, Foul-Mouthed Boys: Women’s Monstrous Laboring Bodies.Amy E. Wendling - 2007 - Radical Philosophy Today 5:49-67.
Added to index2011-09-16
Total downloads10 ( #429,100 of 2,164,555 )
Recent downloads (6 months)1 ( #347,950 of 2,164,555 )
How can I increase my downloads?