Sātmaka, Nairātmya, and A-Nairātmya: Dharmakīrti’s Counter-Argument Against the Proof of Ātman [Book Review]

Journal of Indian Philosophy 39 (4-5):391-410 (2011)

Ātman (soul) and Nairātmya (no soul) are, for the Brahmanical schools and the Buddhists respectively, equally fundamental tenets which neither side can concede to the other. Among the 16 formulations presented by Uddyotakara, the fifteenth, which is a proof of Ātman and is originally an indirect proof ( avīta/āvīta ), is presented in a prasaṅga -style, and contains double negation ( na nairātmyam ) in the thesis. However, it is perhaps Dharmakīrti who first transformed it into a normal style ( sātmakam ). He is well aware of the law of excluded middle, and insisits that the negation is paryudāsa . On the Nyāya side, Uddyotakara at least seems to be unaware of the law of the logical equivalence of contraposition concerning pervasion ( vyāpti ). After Uddyotakara, however, Vyoman (Vyomaśiva), Bhāsarvajña and Vācaspatimiśra, all seem to be well aware of it. Dharmakīrti, in his conter-argument against the proof of ātman , discusses the negative expressions ‘‘ nairātmya ” and ‘‘ a-nairātmya ” Dharmakīrti here uses two logical arguments skillfully and tactically. As a critic of both the authenticity of the Veda and the existence of ātman , he insists on the theory of dichotomy and the equivalence of anvaya and vyatireka , whereas as an apologist he denies the application of these theories to the relation between the existence of ātman and the concept of nairātmya , because for him as a Buddhist the latter is not a negative but essentially positive state of affairs
Keywords Ātman   Prasaṅga   Kevalavyatirekin   Nairātmya   Paryudāsa  Contraposition  Dichotomy
Categories (categorize this paper)
DOI 10.1007/s10781-011-9138-8
Edit this record
Mark as duplicate
Export citation
Find it on Scholar
Request removal from index
Revision history

Download options

Our Archive

Upload a copy of this paper     Check publisher's policy     Papers currently archived: 47,395
External links

Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server
Configure custom proxy (use this if your affiliation does not provide a proxy)
Through your library

References found in this work BETA

Add more references

Citations of this work BETA

No citations found.

Add more citations

Similar books and articles

The Atman: An Ontological Autobiography.Narendra V. Soosania - 1974 - Lund,[the Author, Box 708, 22 00 7 Lund].
On the Nature and the Experience of the Ātman.Narendra V. Soosania - 1974 - Lund[Privately Printed by N. V. Soosania, Box 708, 22 00 7].
The Concepts of Ātman and Paramātman in Indian Thought.S. R. Bhatt - 2005 - Gujarat Vidyasabha, B. J. Institute of Learning & Research.
Dharmakirti and Priest on Change.Chris Mortensen - 2004 - Philosophy East and West 54 (1):20-28.
Consciousness and Brahman-Atman.Mark B. Woodhouse - 1978 - The Monist 61 (January):109-124.


Added to PP index

Total views
31 ( #301,894 of 2,291,328 )

Recent downloads (6 months)
1 ( #827,672 of 2,291,328 )

How can I increase my downloads?


My notes

Sign in to use this feature