Prisoners of Abstraction? The Theory and Measure of Genetic Variation, and the Very Concept of 'Race'

Biological Theory 7 (1):401-412 (2013)
  Copy   BIBTEX


It is illegitimate to read any ontology about "race" off of biological theory or data. Indeed, the technical meaning of "genetic variation" is fluid, and there is no single theoretical agreed-upon criterion for defining and distinguishing populations (or groups or clusters) given a particular set of genetic variation data. Thus, by analyzing three formal senses of "genetic variation"—diversity, differentiation, and heterozygosity—we argue that the use of biological theory for making epistemic claims about "race" can only seem plausible when it relies on the user’s own assumptions about race; the move from biological measures to claims about “race” inevitably amounts to a pernicious reification. We also excavate assumptions in the history of the technical discourse over the concept of "race" (e.g., Livingstone's and Dobzhansky's 1962 exchange, Edwards' 2003 response to Lewontin 1972, as well as contemporary discussions of cladistic "race", and "races" as clusters). We show that claims about the existence (or non-existence) of "race" are underdetermined by biological facts, methods, and theories. Biological theory does not force the concept of "race" upon us; our social discourse, social ontology, and social expectations do. We become prisoners of our abstractions at our own hands, and at our own expense.

Similar books and articles

Race: A Social Destruction of a Biological Concept.Neven Sesardic - 2010 - Biology and Philosophy 25 (2):143-162.
Race Concepts in Medicine.M. O. Hardimon - 2013 - Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 38 (1):6-31.
The Troubling Persistence of Race in Pharmacogenomics.Jonathan Kahn - 2012 - Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics 40 (4):873-885.
The problem of race in medicine.Michael Root - 2001 - Philosophy of the Social Sciences 31 (1):20-39.
Race: Biological reality or social construct?Robin O. Andreasen - 2000 - Philosophy of Science 67 (3):666.
The biological reification of race.Lisa Gannett - 2004 - British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 55 (2):323-345.
The cladistic race concept: A defense.Robin O. Andreasen - 2004 - Biology and Philosophy 19 (3):425-442.
After the Glow: Race ambivalence and other educational prognoses.Zeus Leonardo - 2011 - Educational Philosophy and Theory 43 (6):675-698.


Added to PP

6,275 (#564)

6 months
254 (#3,461)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author Profiles

Rasmus Grønfeldt Winther
University of California, Santa Cruz
Jonathan Kaplan
Oregon State University

Citations of this work

In defense of the metaphysics of race.Adam Hochman - 2017 - Philosophical Studies 174 (11):2709–2729.
Against the New Metaphysics of Race.David Ludwig - 2015 - Philosophy of Science 82 (2):244-265.
The Structure of Scientific Theories.Rasmus Grønfeldt Winther - 2015 - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.

View all 27 citations / Add more citations