Utilitas 8 (3):341-355 (1996)
Abstract |
With a book as wide ranging and insightful as Barry's Justice as Impartiality, it is perhaps a little churlish to criticize it for paying insufficient attention to one's own particular interests. That said, in what follows I am going to do just that and claim that in an important sense Barry does not take utilitarianism seriously. Utilitarianism does receive some discussion in Barry's book, and in an important section which I will discuss he even appears to concede that utilitarianism provides a rival though ultimately inadequate theory of justice. Nevertheless, utilitarianism is not considered a rival to ‘justice as impartiality’ in the way that ‘justice as mutual advantage’ and ‘justice as reciprocity’ are. One response, and perhaps the only adequate response, would be to construct a rival utilitarian theory. I cannot provide such a theory in this paper, and I certainly would be very cautious about claiming that I could provide such a theory elsewhere. What I want to suggest is that utilitarianism is a genuine third theory to contrast with ‘justice as mutual advantage’ and ‘justice as impartiality’ – ‘justice as reciprocity’ being merely a hybrid of ‘justice as mutual advantage’, at least as Barry presents it. I also want to argue that it poses a more significant challenge to a contractualist theory such as Barry's than his discussion of utilitarianism reveals.
|
Keywords | No keywords specified (fix it) |
Categories | (categorize this paper) |
DOI | 10.1017/S0953820800005045 |
Options |
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Download options
References found in this work BETA
Whose Justice? Which Rationality?Alasdair Macintyre - 1988 - Journal of Religious Ethics 16 (2):363-363.
View all 10 references / Add more references
Citations of this work BETA
Similar books and articles
Distributional Equality in Non-Classical Utilitarianism — A Proof of Lerner's Theorem for ‘Utilitarianism Incorporating Justice’.A. Schäfer & R. W. Trapp - 1989 - Theory and Decision 26 (2):157-173.
Utilitarianism and the Theory of Justice.Charles Blackorby, Walter Bossert & D. Donaldson - 1999 - School of Economics, University of Nottingham.
Maximin Justice, Sacrifice, and the Reciprocity Argument: A Pragmatic Reassessment of the Rawls/Nozick Debate: Stephen W. Ball.Stephen W. Ball - 1993 - Utilitas 5 (2):157-184.
A New Approach to Utilitarianism: A Unified Utilitarian Theory and Its Application to Distributive Justice.M. C. G. & C. L. Sheng - 1993 - Philosophical Quarterly 43 (171):275.
Utilitarianism and Distributive Justice: Jeremy Bentham and the Civil Law.P. J. Kelly - 1990 - Oxford University Press.
Theories of Justice: A Treatise on Social Justice, Vol. 1.Brian M. Barry - 1989 - University of California Press.
Theories of Justice: A Treatise on Social Justice, Vol. 1.Brian M. Barry - 1989 - University of California Press.
Much Ado About Nothing?: Barry, Justice and Animals.Robert Garner - 2012 - Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy 15 (3):363-376.
Analytics
Added to PP index
2010-08-30
Total views
96 ( #120,018 of 2,497,778 )
Recent downloads (6 months)
2 ( #283,405 of 2,497,778 )
2010-08-30
Total views
96 ( #120,018 of 2,497,778 )
Recent downloads (6 months)
2 ( #283,405 of 2,497,778 )
How can I increase my downloads?
Downloads