The Tragi‐Comedy of the New Indian Enlightenment: An Essay on the Jingoism of Science and the Pathology of Rationality
Social Epistemology 19 (1):77 – 91 (2005)
AbstractThough the resurgence of Hindu nationalism as a political phenomenon is well-understood, Meera Nanda is correct in suggesting that the ascendancy of Hindutva has other dimensions, such as the avent placed by cultural nationalist on 'Vedic science'. However, apart from this rudimentary insight, Nanda's contribution, far from being a resounding demonstration of potmodernism's complicity in the projects of Hindu nationalism, is a striking testament to her own commitment to a rigidly positivist, ferociously intolerant, and intellectually sterile conception of modern science and the Enlightenment rationality which she views as the pinnacle of human achievement. Nanda displays an impoverished understanding of the scholarly contributions of the last three decades and is unable to countenance the idea of a plurality of sciences; at the same time, in veiw of her deliberate conflation of Hindutva with Hinduism, and her attempts to equate Hinduism as such with Nazism, it is clear that Hinduism itself stands condemned, and not merely resurgent Hindu nationalism. Nanda's book is an indiscriminate and uninteresting assault upon the innumerable enemies of reason, and it is, ironically, likely to have the result of further eroding confidence in self-proclaimed champions of rationality such as herself and the modern science of which she claims herself to be a true and peerless inheritor.
Similar books and articles
Hinduism and Science: The State of the South Asian Science and Religion Discourse.Eric R. Dorman - 2011 - Zygon 46 (3):593-619.
Underdog Epistemologies and the Muscular, Masculine of Science Hindutva.Zaheer Baber - 2005 - Social Epistemology 19 (1):93 – 98.
Postmodernism and Religious Fundamentalism: A Scientific Rebuttal to Hindu Science: An Essay, a Review and an Interview.Meera Nanda - 2003 - Navayana.
Scientific Temper: Arguments for an Indian Enlightenment.Meera Nanda - 2010 - In Aakash Singh & Silika Mohapatra (eds.), Indian Political Thought: A Reader. Routledge.
On Seeing the Generative Possibilities of Dalit Neo‐Buddhist Thought.Helen Verran - 2005 - Social Epistemology 19 (1):33 – 48.
"Prophet" Looking for a Nineteenth Century Future.Susantha Goonatilake - 2005 - Social Epistemology 19 (1):129 – 146.
“Science and Democracy:” Replayed or Redesigned?Sandra Harding - 2005 - Social Epistemology 19 (1):5 – 18.
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads
Citations of this work
No citations found.
References found in this work
Goethe's Way of Science: A Phenomenology of Nature.David Seamon & Arthur Zajonc (eds.) - 1998 - State University of New York Press.
Traditions, Tyranny, and Utopias: Essays in the Politics of Awareness.Ashis Nandy - 1987 - Oxford University Press.
Lokayata a Study in Ancient Indian Materialism.Debiprasad Chattopadhyaya - 1959 - People's Pub. House.
Fashionable Nonsense: Postmodern Intellectuals' Abuse of Science.Alan Sokal & Jean Bricmont - 1998 - Picador.