Ethics 122 (1):8-9 (2011)
AbstractMcMahan’s book develops each of these themes: rejection of the moral equality of soldiers, introduction and defense of his criterion of liability to lethal attack, and resistance to its unsavory implications for noncombatant immunity. The contributions to this symposium focus on the first two themes. John Gardner and Franc¸ois Tanguay-Renaud make a plea for culpability, testing McMahan’s endorsement of a thinner standard of responsibility for liability, while David Rodin’s paper explores the implications of McMahan’s novel analysis of proportionality in self defense, asking whether the proportionality metaphor can be extended even further than McMahan considers. Cheyney Ryan and Yitzhak Benbaji each argue that the intuitions underlying the moral equality of soldiers have firmer foundations than McMahan allows—Ryan aiming to develop the democratic justification for military obedience; Benbaji seeking to defend a more holistic contractarian justification of the conventional principles governing conduct in war. McMahan then offers a detailed response to his critics.
Similar books and articles
Responsibility, Risk, and Killing in Self‐Defense.Seth Lazar - 2009 - Ethics 119 (4):699-728.
Porphyry. Introduction, Translated with an Introduction and Commentary by Jonathan Barnes.Andrea Falcon - 2006 - Ancient Philosophy 26 (2):462-466.
Introduction. Editors' Introduction.Oskari Kuusela & Marie McGinn - 2011 - In Marie McGinn & Oskari Kuusela (eds.), Dialogue and Universalism. Oxford University Press. pp. 10-14.
"Introduction to Structuralism," Edited with Introduction by Michael Lane.Lee C. Rice - 1972 - Modern Schoolman 49 (4):380-381.
The Responsibility Dilemma for Killing in War: A Review Essay.Seth Lazar - 2010 - Philosophy and Public Affairs 38 (2):180-213.
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads
Citations of this work
Rodin on Self-Defense and the "Myth" of National Self-Defense: A Refutation.Uwe Steinhoff - 2013 - Philosophia 41 (4):1017-1036.
References found in this work
No references found.