Erkenntnis 58 (2):229 - 260 (2003)
On the orthodox view in economics, interpersonal comparisons of utility are not empirically meaningful, and "hence" impossible. To reassess this view, this paper draws on the parallels between the problem of interpersonal comparisons of utility and the problem of translation of linguistic meaning, as explored by Quine. I discuss several cases of what the empirical evidence for interpersonal comparisonsof utility might be and show that, even on the strongest of these, interpersonal comparisons are empirically underdetermined and, if we also deny any appropriate truth of the matter, indeterminate. However, the underdetermination can be broken non-arbitrarily (though not purely empirically) if (i) we assign normative significance to certain states of affairs or (ii) we posit a fixed connection between certain empirically observable proxies and utility. I conclude that, even if interpersonal comparisons are not empirically meaningful, they are not in principle impossible.
|Keywords||Utility Welfare Interpersonal comparisons Empirical underdetermination Indeterminacy Quine|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
References found in this work BETA
No references found.
Citations of this work BETA
Transformative Experience and Interpersonal Utility Comparisons.Rachael Briggs - 2015 - Res Philosophica 92 (2):189-216.
Prioritarianism for Variable Populations.Campbell Brown - 2007 - Philosophical Studies 134 (3):325-361.
Rational Cooperation and the Nash Bargaining Solution.Michael Moehler - 2015 - Ethical Theory and Moral Practice 18 (3):577-594.
Comparing Evaluations.Richard Bradley - 2008 - Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society 108 (1part1):85-100.
Can Unstable Preferences Provide a Stable Standard of Well-Being?Krister Bykvist - 2010 - Economics and Philosophy 26 (1):1-26.
Similar books and articles
Interpersonal Comparisons of Well-Being, the Evaluative Attitudes, and Type Correspondence Between Mind and Brain.JP Sevilla - manuscript
The Impossibility of Interpersonal Utility Comparisons: A Critical Note.Ruth Weintraub - 1996 - Mind 105 (420):661-665.
Extended Sympathy and Interpersonal Utility Comparisons.Alfred F. MacKay - 1986 - Journal of Philosophy 83 (6):305-322.
Discussion. The Impossibility of Interpersonal Utility Comparisons - a Reply.DM Hausman - 1997 - Mind 106 (421):99-100.
The Impossibility of Interpersonal Utility Comparisons--A Reply.Daniel M. Hausman - 1997 - Mind 106 (421):99-100.
The Impossibility of Interpersonal Utility Comparisons.Daniel M. Hausman - 1995 - Mind 104 (415):473-490.
Transcendental Arguments and Interpersonal Utility Comparisons.Mauro Rossi - 2011 - Economics and Philosophy 27 (03):273-295.
Interpersonal Utility in Principles of Social Choice.Paul Weirich - 1984 - Erkenntnis 21 (3):295 - 317.
Added to index2009-01-28
Total downloads98 ( #51,886 of 2,168,604 )
Recent downloads (6 months)5 ( #61,319 of 2,168,604 )
How can I increase my downloads?