Overlapping Ontologies and Indigenous Knowledge. From Integration to Ontological Self-Determination
Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part A 59:36-45 (2016)
AbstractCurrent controversies about knowledge integration reflect conflicting ideas of what it means to “take Indigenous knowledge seriously”. While there is increased interest in integrating Indigenous and Western scientific knowledge in various disciplines such as anthropology and ethnobiology, integration projects are often accused of recognizing Indigenous knowledge only insofar as it is useful for Western scientists. The aim of this article is to use tools from philosophy of science to develop a model of both successful integration and integration failures. On the one hand, I argue that cross-cultural recognition of property clusters leads to an ontological overlap that makes knowledge integration often epistemically productive and socially useful. On the other hand, I argue that knowledge integration is limited by ontological divergence. Adequate models of Indigenous knowledge will therefore have to take integration failures seriously and I argue that integration efforts need to be complemented by a political notion of ontological self-determination.
Similar books and articles
A Conceptual Investigation of the Ontological Commensurability of Spatial Data Infrastructures Among Different Cultures.D. J. Saab - 2009 - Earth Science Informatics 2 (4):283-297.
Marginalized Knowledge: An Agenda for Indigenous Knowledge Development and Integration with Other Forms of Knowledge.Dennis Ocholla - 2007 - International Review of Information Ethics 7 (9-2007):236-245.
A Strategy for Improving and Integrating Biomedical Ontologies.Cornelius Rosse, Anand Kumar, Jose L. V. Mejino, Daniel L. Cook, Landon T. Detwiler & Barry Smith - 2005 - In Proceedings of the Annual Symposium of the American Medical Informatics Association. AMIA. pp. 639-643.
Self-Determination Versus the Determination of Self: A Critical Reading of the Colonial Ethics Inherent to the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples.Mark F. N. Franke - 2007 - Journal of Global Ethics 3 (3):359 – 379.
Indigenous Knowledge and its Implication for Agricultural Development and Agricultural Education: A Case Study of the Vedic Tradition in Nepal.Anthony B. J. Willett - 1993 - Dissertation, Iowa State University
Integrating Indigenous Knowledge and Soil Science to Develop a National Soil Classification System for Nigeria.Ademola K. Braimoh - 2002 - Agriculture and Human Values 19 (1):75-80.
Indigeneity, Self-Determination, and Sovereignty.Anne Schulherr Waters - 2002 - American Philosophical Association Newsletter on American Indians in Philosophy.
Indigenous Ecological Knowledge and Modern Western Ecological Knowledge: Complementary, Not Contradictory.Jacinta Mwende Maweu - 2011 - Thought and Practice: A Journal of the Philosophical Association of Kenya 3 (2):35-47.
Persistence and Ontological Pluralism.Pierre Grenon & Barry Smith - 2007 - In Christian Kanzian (ed.), Persistence. Ontos. pp. 33-48.
Building on Tradition: Indigenous Irrigation Knowledge and Sustainable Development in Asia. [REVIEW]David Groenfeldt - 1991 - Agriculture and Human Values 8 (1-2):114-120.
Interview With Anne Waters - Transcribed Sections of Interview Filmed At the Indigenous Knowledge and BioProspecting Conference, MacQuarie University, Sydney, Australia 2004.Evans Omari - 2005 - American Philosophical Association Newsletter on American Indians in Philosophy Vol. 4, #2, Spring 2005.
Bity i byty. O pewnym mało znanym zastosowaniu ontologii.Paweł Garbacz - 2007 - Filozofia Nauki 3 (59):121--140.
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads
Citations of this work
Letting Go of “Natural Kind”: Toward a Multidimensional Framework of Nonarbitrary Classification.David Ludwig - 2018 - Philosophy of Science 85 (1):31-52.
Ethnoontology: Ways of World‐Building Across Cultures.David Ludwig & Daniel A. Weiskopf - 2019 - Philosophy Compass (9):1-11.
Relating Traditional and Academic Ecological Knowledge: Mechanistic and Holistic Epistemologies Across Cultures.David Ludwig & Luana Poliseli - 2018 - Biology and Philosophy 33 (5-6):43.
Revamping the Metaphysics of Ethnobiological Classification.David Ludwig - 2018 - Current Anthropology 59 (4):415-438.
Philosophy of Ethnobiology: Understanding Knowledge Integration and Its Limitations.David Ludwig & Charbel N. El-Hani - forthcoming - Journal of Ethnobiology.
References found in this work
Scientific Kinds.Marc Ereshefsky & Thomas A. C. Reydon - 2015 - Philosophical Studies 172 (4):969-986.
Three Kinds of Social Kinds.Muhammad Ali Khalidi - 2015 - Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 90 (1):96-112.
Natural Kinds as Categorical Bottlenecks.Laura Franklin-Hall - 2015 - Philosophical Studies 172 (4):925-948.
Natural Kinds: Rosy Dawn, Scholastic Twilight.Ian Hacking - 2007 - Royal Institute of Philosophy Supplement 61:203-239.