From Child Protection to Paradigm Protection—The Genesis, Development, and Defense of a Scientific Paradigm
Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 44 (3):378-390 (2019)
AbstractA scientific paradigm typically embraces research norms and values, such as truth-seeking, critical thinking, disinterestedness, and good scientific practice. These values should prevent a paradigm from introducing defective assumptions. But sometimes, scientists who are also physicians develop clinical norms that are in conflict with the scientific enterprise. As an example of such a conflict, we have analyzed the genesis and development of the shaken baby syndrome paradigm. The point of departure of the analysis is a recently conducted systematic literature review, which concluded that there is very low scientific evidence for the basic assumption held by Child Protection Teams: when certain signs are present the infant has been violently shaken. We suggest that such teams have developed more value-based than scientific-based criteria when classifying SBS cases. Further, we suggest that the teams are victims of “groupthink,” aggravating the difficulties in considering critics’ questioning the criteria established by the teams.
Similar books and articles
Organisational Development Issues and the Implementation of the Clean Technology Paradigm in Industry.Rita Vorst - 1998 - AI and Society 12 (1-2):48-54.
Kuhnian Revolutions in Neuroscience: The Role of Tool Development.David Parker - 2018 - Biology and Philosophy 33 (3-4):17.
Privacy and Protection of Marginalized Social Groups.Stephen Kabera Karanja - 2009 - Studies in Ethics, Law, and Technology 2 (3).
Relativity Current Paradigm with Unresolved Anomalies.Alfonso Leon Guillen Gomez - 2014 - Journal of Modern Physics 5:364-374.
A Health-Based Child Protection System: Studying a Change in Paradigm.Richard D. Krugman, Stephanie Stronks-Knapp, Mischa Haroutunian & Jessica M. Yeatermeyer - 2008 - Journal of Clinical Ethics 19 (4):346-349.
Przyczynek do krytyki tendencji naukocentrycznych we współczesnej ochronie przyrody.Adam P. Kubiak - 2010 - Roczniki Filozoficzne 58 (2):5-26.
Aesthetic Implications of the New Paradigm in Ecology.Jason Boaz Simus - 2008 - Journal of Aesthetic Education 42 (1):63-79.
An Evaluation and Redefinition of Parameters in the Classical Psychoanalytic Paradigm.Hattie Beth Myers - 1996 - Dissertation, New York University
„Niekoľko poznámok k vzťahu prírodných a spoločenských vied.“.Ladislav Kvasz - 2003 - Organon F: Medzinárodný Časopis Pre Analytickú Filozofiu 10 (2):157-172.
The Paradigm‐Case Argument and 'Possible Doubt'1.Laurence D. Houlgate - 1962 - Inquiry: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Philosophy 5 (1-4):318-324.
Does the New Paradigm in Ape-Language Research Ape Behaviorism?Joseph J. Pear - 2002 - Behavioral and Brain Sciences 25 (5):635-636.
Bayesian Test and Kuhn’s Paradigm.Chen Xiaoping - 2006 - Frontiers of Philosophy in China 1 (3):491-505.
Epistemology in the Context of the Modern Biological Evolutional Paradigm.О. S. Tokovenko - 2014 - Anthropological Measurements of Philosophical Research 6:125-131.
Phronesis and the Physician: A Defense of the Practical Paradigm of Clinical Rationality.Frank Daniel Davis - 1996 - Dissertation, Georgetown University
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads
Citations of this work
Vulnerability and Obligation in Science and Medicine.Jeremy Weissman - 2019 - Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 44 (3):263-278.
The Unspoken Shaken Baby Lie Detector Algorithm - An Analysis of Diagnostic Procedures in Cases of Allegedly Abusive Head Trauma Without External Signs of Trauma.Niels Lynøe & Anders Eriksson - 2020 - Journal of Research in Philosophy and History 2 (3).
References found in this work
The Structure of Scientific Revolutions.Thomas Samuel Kuhn - 1962 - Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Bioethics Skill Sets Can Work, But It Would Take Moral Courage to Apply Them and Get Desired Results.Stephen Sodeke - 2016 - American Journal of Bioethics 16 (4):19-21.
Infant Homicide and Accidental Death in the United States, 1940-2005: Ethics and Epidemiological Classification.J. E. Riggs & G. R. Hobbs - 2011 - Journal of Medical Ethics 37 (7):445-448.