Libertarian Agency and Rational Morality: Action-Theoretic Objections to Gauthier's Dispositional Soution of the Compliance Problem
Southern Journal of Philosophy 26 (4):499-525 (1988)
David Gauthier thinks agents facing a prisoner's dilemma ('pd') should find it rational to dispose themselves to co-operate with those inclined to reciprocate (i.e., to acquire a constrained maximizer--'cm'--disposition), and to co-operate with other 'cmers'. Richmond Campbell argues that since dominance reasoning shows it remains to the agent's advantage to defect, his co-operation is only rational if cm "determines" him to co-operate, forcing him not to cheat. I argue that if cm "forces" the agent to co-operate, he is not acting at all, never mind rationally. Thus, neither author has shown that co-operation is rational action in a pd.
|Keywords||prisoners dilemma preference revision constrained maximization free will David Gauthier|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
References found in this work BETA
Intending and Acting: Toward a Naturalized Action Theory.Myles Brand - 1984 - Journal of Philosophy 84 (1):49-54.
Review: Gauthier's Theory of Morals by Agreement. [REVIEW]Richmond Campbell - 1988 - Philosophical Quarterly 38 (152):343 - 364.
Citations of this work BETA
The Individual Rationality of Maintaining a Sense of Justice.Eric M. Cave - 1996 - Theory and Decision 41 (3):229-256.
Similar books and articles
The Moral Law as Causal Law.Robert N. Johnson - 2009 - In Jens Timmermann (ed.), Kant's Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals: A Critical Guide. Cambridge University Press.
Co-Operative Solutions to the Prisoner's Dilemma.Duncan Macintosh - 1991 - Philosophical Studies 64 (3):309 - 321.
Categorically Rational Preferences and the Structure of Morality.Duncan MacIntosh - 1998 - In Peter Danielson (ed.), Modeling Rationality, Morality and Evolution; Vancouver Studies in Cognitive Science, Volume 7. Oxford University Press.
The Transcendental Necessity of Morality.Joseph Heath - 2003 - Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 67 (2):378–395.
Preference's Progress: Rational Self-Alteration and the Rationality of Morality.Duncan MacIntosh - 1991 - Dialogue 30 (1991):3-32.
Retaliation Rationalized: Gauthier's Solution to the Deterrence Dilemma.Duncan MacIntosh - 1991 - Pacific Philosophical Quarterly 72 (1):9-32.
McClennen's Early Co-Operative Solution to the Prisoner's Dilemma.Duncan MacIntosh - 1991 - Southern Journal of Philosophy 29 (3):341-358.
Constrained Maximization Reconsidered — an Elaboration and Critique of Gauthier's Modelling of Rational Cooperation in a Single Prisoner's Dilemma.Maarten Franssen - 1994 - Synthese 101 (2):249 - 272.
Buridan and the Circumstances of Justice (On the Implications of the Rational Unsolvability of Certain Co-Ordination Problems).Duncan MacIntosh - 1992 - Pacific Philosophical Quarterly 73 (2):150-173.
Added to index2010-06-22
Total downloads153 ( #29,441 of 2,152,215 )
Recent downloads (6 months)8 ( #89,723 of 2,152,215 )
How can I increase my downloads?
There are no threads in this forum
Nothing in this forum yet.