Medicine without Cure?: A Cluster Analysis of the Nature of Medicine

Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 43 (3):306-312 (2018)
  Copy   BIBTEX


Part of a symposium devoted to ‘Prediction, Understanding, and Medicine’, in which Alex Broadbent argues that the nature of medicine is determined by its competences, i.e., which things it can do well. He argues that, although medicine cannot cure well, it can do a good job of enabling people not only to understand states of the human organism and of what has caused them, but also to predict future states of it. From this Broadbent concludes that medicine is (at least in part) essentially a practice of understanding and predicting, not curing. In reply to this bold position, I mount two major criticisms. First, I maintain that the reasons Broadbent gives for doubting that medicine can cure provide comparable reason for doubting that medicine can provide an understanding; roughly, the best explanation of why medicine cannot reliably cure is that we still lack much understanding of health and disease. Second, I object to the claim that a practice is medical only if it facilitates understanding and prediction. Although Broadbent has brought to light certain desirable purposes of medicine that are under-appreciated, my conclusion is that he has not yet provided enough reason to think that understanding and prediction are essential to it. Instead of supposing that medicine has an essence, in fact, I suggest that its nature is best understood in terms of a property cluster.

Similar books and articles

How to Make Real, Constructive, Progress in Medicine.Jeremy R. Simon - 2011 - Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice 17 (5):847-851.
Information in the Universe and in the Organism.Ervin Laszlo - 2016 - World Futures 72 (3-4):101-106.
Human nature, medicine & health care.Bert Gordijn & Wim Dekkers - 2009 - Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 12 (2):119-119.
Transplant Medicine as Borderline Medicine.Volker H. Schmidt - 2003 - Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 6 (3):319-321.
Medicine and humanistic understanding.Jerry Vannatta - 2005 - Philadelphia, [Pa.]: University of Pennsylvania Press. Edited by Ronald Schleifer & Sheila Crow.
Ideas and ideals in medicine: fruits of reason or props of power?Olli S. Miettinen - 1999 - Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice 5 (2):107-116.
The evolution of Western medicine.Henrik R. Wulff - 1998 - Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 1 (1):79-81.


Added to PP

290 (#61,941)

6 months
112 (#28,229)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author's Profile

References found in this work

Prediction, Understanding, and Medicine.Alex Broadbent - 2018 - Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 43 (3):289-305.

Add more references