Why Reconciliation Requires Punishment but Not Forgiveness

In Krisanna Scheiter & Paula Satne (eds.), Conflict and Resolution: The Ethics of Forgiveness, Revenge, and Punishment. Springer. pp. 265-281 (2022)
  Copy   BIBTEX


Adherents to reconciliation, restorative justice, and related approaches to dealing with social conflict are well known for seeking to minimize punishment, in favor of offenders hearing out victims, making an apology, and effecting compensation for wrongful harm as well as victims forgiving offenders and accepting their reintegration into society. In contrast, I maintain that social reconciliation and similar concepts in fact characteristically require punishment but do not require forgiveness. I argue that a reconciliatory response to crime that includes punitive disavowal but not necessarily forgiveness is supported by an analogy with resolving two-person conflict and by relational facets of human dignity. I also specify a novel account of the type of penalty that is justified by reconciliation, namely, burdensome labor that is likely to foster moral reform on the part of wrongdoers and to compensate their victims, which would serve neither retributive nor deterrent functions. I illustrate this conception of punishment in contexts that include having cheated on an exam at a university, engaged in criminal behavior such as robbery, and committed atrocities during large-scale social conflict.



External links

Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server

Through your library

Similar books and articles

Punishment, Forgiveness and Reconciliation.Bill Wringe - 2016 - Philosophia 44 (4):1099-1124.
The dilemma of divine forgiveness.Glen Pettigrove - 2008 - Religious Studies 44 (4):457-464.
Forgiveness and Reconciliation.Barrett Emerick - 2017 - In Kathryn J. Norlock (ed.), The Moral Psychology of Forgiveness. Rowman & Littlefield International. pp. 117-134.
The personal and the political: forgiveness and reconciliation in restorative justice.Ari Kohen - 2009 - Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy 12 (3):399-423.
reconciling With Harm: An Alternative To Forgiveness And Revenge.Nancy Stanlick - 2010 - Florida Philosophical Review 10 (1):88-111.
Divine Forgiveness and Reconciliation.Jada Twedt Strabbing - 2017 - Faith and Philosophy 34 (3):272-297.
Is Amnesty a Collective Act of Forgiveness?Christopher Bennett - 2003 - Contemporary Political Theory 2 (1):67-76.
Punishment and Forgiveness.Justin Tosi & Brandon Warmke - 2016 - In Jonathan Jacobs & Jonathan Jackson (eds.), The Routledge Handbook of Criminal Justice Ethics. Routledge. pp. 203-216.
Forgiving enemies in Ireland.Nigel Biggar - 2008 - Journal of Religious Ethics 36 (4):559-579.


Added to PP

574 (#29,111)

6 months
222 (#10,185)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author's Profile

Thaddeus Metz
Cornell University (PhD)

Citations of this work

Post-conflict amnesties and/as plea bargains.Patrick Lenta - 2023 - Journal of Global Ethics 19 (2):188-205.
Can transitional amnesties promote restorative justice?Patrick Lenta - forthcoming - Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy.

Add more citations