Sex, lies and gender

Journal of Medical Ethics 43 (1):14-16 (2017)

Authors
Irina Mikhalevich
Rochester Institute of Technology
Russell Powell
Boston University
Abstract
Browne 1 (this issue ) argues that what may appear to be a benevolent practice-disclosing the sex of a fetus to expecting parents who wish to know-is in fact an epistemically problematic and, as a result, ethically questionable medical practice. Browne worries that not only will the disclosure of fetal sex encourage sex-selective abortions (an issue we will not take up here), but also that it will convey a misleading and pernicious message about the relationship between sex and gender. More specifically, she contends that the practice of disclosure is problematic because (1) it purports to establish the gender of the developing baby based on information about the baby's sex, whereas this is not a warranted inference because while sex is determined by biological factors, gender is determined by social factors and (2) it conflates (biological) sex with (social) gender or encourages such conflation or reduction and thereby promotes 'essentialistic' thinking about gender that is closely linked to sexism and social injustice. If (1) is true, then disclosing fetal sex amounts to misinforming or misleading prospective parents-and since misinforming patients is wrong, the act of disclosing is also wrong. However, beyond the wrongs of misinforming patients, the practice also perpetuates the harms associated with a rigidly gendered society through endorsing the message in (2), thus lending the authority of the medical profession to the gender-essentialist ideas that have underpinned, and continue to drive, sexism and social injustice. This analysis leads Browne to recommend that clinicians be prohibited from informing parents about the sex of their developing fetus. We agree with Browne that gender essentialism-the notion that 'femaleness' and 'maleness' carve out distinct natural classes with innate, immutable properties-is not only a false metaphysical thesis, but also a pernicious idea insofar as the sexist attitudes it fosters motivate policies that systematically violate the human rights of women, as well as those of the LGBTQ community. However, we do not think that the disclosure of fetal sex misinforms prospective parents about the gender of their baby, nor do we believe that such disclosure presupposes or promotes gender essentialism properly understood.
Keywords sex, gender, fetal sex, pregnancy, biological determinism, LGBTQ, gender essentialism
Categories (categorize this paper)
DOI 10.1136/medethics-2016-103380
Options
Edit this record
Mark as duplicate
Export citation
Find it on Scholar
Request removal from index
Revision history

Download options

Our Archive
External links

Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server
Configure custom proxy (use this if your affiliation does not provide a proxy)
Through your library

References found in this work BETA

The Extreme Male Brain Theory of Autism.Simon Baron-Cohen - 2002 - Trends in Cognitive Sciences 6 (6):248-254.

Add more references

Citations of this work BETA

No citations found.

Add more citations

Similar books and articles

Book of Lies.Lloyd Bradley (ed.) - 2005 - Andrews Mcmeel.
Gender Reality.Sr Mary Prudence Allen - 2014 - Solidarity: The Journal for Catholic Social Thought and Secular Ethics 4 (1):Article 1.
A Dispositional Account of Gender.Jennifer McKitrick - 2015 - Philosophical Studies 172 (10):2575-2589.
Who's Afraid of Feminism? [REVIEW]Susan Dwyer - 1996 - Dialogue 35 (2):327-342.
Gender Thinking.Steven G. Smith - 1992 - Temple University Press.
Bald-Faced Lies! Lying Without the Intent to Deceive.Roy Sorensen - 2007 - Pacific Philosophical Quarterly 88 (2):251-264.
Undoing Gender.J. Butler - 2004 - Routledge.
The Magic of Language: Genders in the Language of Myths.Dan-ya Lin - 2008 - Nankai University (Philosophy and Social Sciences) 4:23-31.
Thinking About Gender.Julie A. Nelson - 1992 - Hypatia 7 (3):138-154.
Gender and "Postmodern War".Robin May Schott - 1996 - Hypatia 11 (4):19 - 29.

Analytics

Added to PP index
2017-06-25

Total views
36 ( #223,029 of 2,242,907 )

Recent downloads (6 months)
19 ( #40,051 of 2,242,907 )

How can I increase my downloads?

Downloads

My notes

Sign in to use this feature