Pursuing multiple goals in European Parliamentary Debates: EU immigration policies as a case in point
Journal of Argumentation in Context 2 (1):47-74 (2013)
AbstractIn this paper I shed light on the multi-purposive nature of debates in the European Parliament. As a case in point, I examine a debate on immigration in the wake of a migratory crisis in the Italian island of Lampedusa in early 2011. I analyze the points of view argued for by MEPs, aiming at identifying the different institutional goals that are typically pursued and characterizing the ways in which these goals shape the argumentative exchanges. The link between the multiple goals communicators have and the discourse choices they make can be assumed on the basis of previous research. In line with the pragma-dialectical view of argumentative discourse taking place in the context of more or less institutionalized argumentative activity types, institutional goals are understood as those goals that can be attributed to arguers on the basis of the type of activity in which they are engaged. In identifying the institutional goals, I follow Craig and consider not only goals which are intentional, formal, and directly responsible for a certain discourse choice, but also goals which are functional, strategic, and only indirectly responsible for discourse choices. The analysis shows that the MEPs pursued three kinds of goals: goals that are 1) assigned to them by the occasion of the debate; 2) related to the powers of Parliament; and 3) associated with the different identities they assume in Parliament. While the pursuit of the occasion-related and powers-related goals gave rise to multiple simultaneous discussions, the pursuit of the identity-related goals guided the MEPs’ choices and formulations in these discussions.
Similar books and articles
W Hat is a Goal? How Do People Pursue Goals? The Answers to These Questions May Seem Obvious Because People Have a Lifetime of Experience at Setting Goals, Pursuing Goals, Disengaging From Some Goals, and Attaining Others. One's History of Experience with Goals, However, Does Not Mean That One has an Accurate Understanding of Where Goals Come From, How the Mind Represents Them, or How One Goes About Pursuing the Aims That Are so Central to One's Sense of Personal Fulfillment.Gordon B. Moskowitz - 2012 - In Henk Aarts & Andrew J. Elliot (eds.), Goal-Directed Behavior. Psychology Press.
Immigration Justice: A Principle for Selecting Just Admissions Policies.Peter W. Higgins - 2009 - Social Philosophy Today 25:149-162.
Imprisoned by a Doctrine: The Modern Defence of Parliamentary Sovereignty.Vernon Bogdanor - 2012 - Oxford Journal of Legal Studies 32 (1):179-195.
Towards a Non-Positivist Approach to Cosmopolitan Immigration: A Critique of the Inclusion/Exclusion Dialectic and an Analysis of Selected European Immigration Policies.Mason Richey - 2010 - Journal of International and Area Studies 17 (1):55-74.
Japan in the ‘Global War for Talent’: Changing Concepts of Valuable Foreign Workers and Their Consequences.David Chiavacci - 2012 - .
Agents of the People: Democracy and Popular Sovereignty in British and Swedish Parliamentary and Public Debates, 1734–1800.Pasi Ihalainen - 2010 - Brill.
Post-National Citizenship Without Post-National Identity? A Case Study of UK Immigration Policy and Intra-EU Migration.Katherine E. Tonkiss - 2013 - Journal of Global Ethics 9 (1):35-48.
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads
Citations of this work
Goals in Argumentation: A Proposal for the Analysis and Evaluation of Public Political Arguments.Dima Mohammed - 2016 - Argumentation 30 (3):221-245.
Standing Standpoints and Argumentative Associates: What is at Stake in a Public Political Argument?Dima Mohammed - 2019 - Argumentation 33 (3):307-322.
Reasoning and Arguing, Dialectically and Dialogically, Among Individual and Multiple Participants.Michael D. Baumtrog - 2018 - Argumentation 32 (1):77-98.
Handbook of Argumentation Theory.Frans Hendrik van Eemeren, Erik Bart Garssen, A. Francisca Snoeck Henkemans C. W. Krabbe, Jean Bart Verheij & H. M. Wagemans - 2014 - Dordrecht, Netherland: Springer.
References found in this work
No references found.