Shall parent / patient wishes be fulfilled in any case? A series of 32 ethics consultations: from reproductive medicine to neonatology
BMC Medical Ethics 20 (1):4 (2019)
AbstractQuestions concerning the parent/ patient’s autonomy are seen as one of the most important reasons for requesting Ethics Consultations. Respecting parent/ patient’s autonomy also means respecting the patient’s wishes. But those wishes may be controversial and sometimes even go beyond legal requirements. The objective of this case series of 32 ECs was to illustrate ethically challenging parent / patients’ wishes during the first stages of life and how the principle of patient’s autonomy was handled. The case series has a qualitative retrospective approach. A documentary sheet was designed de novo and information was gained from EC minutes and medical charts. The cases originate from the following specialties: reproductive medicine, obstetrics and neonatology as well as two interdisciplinary cases. Through the structured EC minutes aspects of patient / parents’ wishes could be identified explicitly. Overall the patient / parents’ wishes were not supported in 61% of the cases. Central reasons for rejection of patient / parent wishes were mainly the protection of the best interest of the unborn / new-born child as well as the rejection of clinical approaches that were regarded as being substandard treatment. The study shows that treatment decisions in reproductive medicine, obstetrics and neonatology raise substantial ethical questions leading to the request for ethics consultation. The systematic case series presented here gives insight into the ethical reflection carried out to support the clinicians in their decision-making and counselling. It shows that clinicians, after using ethics consultation, make deliberate decisions that do not “automatically” fulfil the treatment requests of the patients and parents.
Similar books and articles
How Family Caregivers' Medical and Moral Assumptions Influence Decision Making for Patients in the Vegetative State: A Qualitative Interview Study.Katja Kuehlmeyer, Gian Domenico Borasio & Ralf J. Jox - 2012 - Journal of Medical Ethics 38 (6):332-337.
Autonomy, Religion and Clinical Decisions: Findings From a National Physician Survey.R. E. Lawrence & F. A. Curlin - 2009 - Journal of Medical Ethics 35 (4):214-218.
Parents Refusing Treatment of the Child: A Discussion About Child’s Health Right and Parental Paternalism.Cemal Hüseyin Güvercin & Berna Arda - 2013 - Clinical Ethics 8 (2-3):52-60.
What Ethical Issues Really Arise in Practice at an Academic Medical Center? A Quantitative and Qualitative Analysis of Clinical Ethics Consultations From 2008 to 2013.Katherine Wasson, Emily Anderson, Erika Hagstrom, Michael McCarthy, Kayhan Parsi & Mark Kuczewski - 2016 - HEC Forum 28 (3):217-228.
Proxy Consent and Counterfactual Wishes.Edward Wierenga - 1983 - Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 8 (4):405-416.
Decision‐Making for an Incapacitated Pregnant Patient.Hilary Mabel, Susannah L. Rose & Eric Kodish - 2017 - Hastings Center Report 47 (4):12-15.
Information Disclosure and Decision-Making: The Middle East Versus the Far East and the West.A. F. Mobeireek, F. Al-Kassimi, K. Al-Zahrani, A. Al-Shimemeri, S. al-Damegh, O. Al-Amoudi, S. Al-Eithan, B. Al-Ghamdi & M. Gamal-Eldin - 2008 - Journal of Medical Ethics 34 (4):225-229.
Evaluating Parents' Perspectives of Pediatric Ethics Consultation.Frances Rieth Ward - 2013 - HEC Forum 25 (2):183-189.
Patient Autonomy in Emergency Medicine.Anne-Cathrine Naess, Reidun Foerde & Petter Andreas Steen - 2001 - Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 4 (1):71-77.
Tell Me What's Wrong with Me: A Discourse Analysis Approach to the Concept of Patient Autonomy.J. Nessa & K. Malterud - 1998 - Journal of Medical Ethics 24 (6):394-400.
An Obstructed Death and Medical Ethics -- A Case Conference Revisited: Commentary.Roger Higgs - 1990 - Journal of Medical Ethics 16 (2):90-92.
Ethical Decision-Making in Two Patients with Locked-in Syndrome on the Intensive Care Unit.E. J. O. Kompanje - 2009 - Clinical Ethics 4 (2):98-101.
What Triggers Requests for Ethics Consultations?G. DuVal - 2001 - Journal of Medical Ethics 27 (suppl 1):24-29.
Development of a Hospital Ethics Committee: Lessons From Five Years of Case Consultations.William S. Andereck - 1992 - Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics 1 (1):41.
Doctors' Authoritarianism in End-of-Life Treatment Decisions. A Comparison Between Russia, Sweden and Germany.J. Richter - 2001 - Journal of Medical Ethics 27 (3):186-191.
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads
Citations of this work
Ethics Consultation in U.S. Hospitals: A National Follow-Up Study.Ellen Fox, Marion Danis, Anita J. Tarzian & Christopher C. Duke - 2021 - American Journal of Bioethics 22 (4):5-18.
Ethics Experts and Fetal Patients: A Proposal for Modesty.Angus Clarke & Dagmar Schmitz - 2021 - BMC Medical Ethics 22 (1):1-7.
References found in this work
Evaluating Clinical Ethics Consultation: A European Perspective.Margarete Pfäfflin, Klaus Kobert & Stella Reiter-Theil - 2009 - Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics 18 (4):406.
To Evaluate the Effectiveness of Health Care Ethics Consultation Based on the Goals of Health Care Ethics Consultation: A Prospective Cohort Study with Randomization.Yen-Yuan Chen, Tzong-Shinn Chu, Yu-Hui Kao, Pi-Ru Tsai, Tien-Shang Huang & Wen-Je Ko - 2014 - BMC Medical Ethics 15 (1):1.
Dealing with the Normative Dimension in Clinical Ethics Consultation.Stella Reiter-Theil - 2009 - Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics 18 (4):347.
Balancing the Perspectives. The Patient’s Role in Clinical Ethics Consultation.Stella Reiter-Theil - 2003 - Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 6 (3):247-254.
Initiating and Maintaining Clinical Ethics Support in Psychiatry. Ten Tasks and Challenges – And How to Meet Them.Stella Reiter-Theil - 2016 - Clinical Ethics 11 (2-3):45-53.