The prophasis of desertion

Classical Quarterly 36 (01):262- (1986)
  Copy   BIBTEX

Abstract

This statement, in Nicias' letter from Sicily, has puzzled readers and editors, and it has baffled translators, who expect phrases with π προάσει to indicate a pretext or ostensible reason for an action. In my first discussion of prophasis I suggested that ‘what Nicias means is that they are leaving without offering any other reason or pretext’ , and Dover, in the Historical Commentary, goes halfway towards accepting this interpretation ; but it does not satisfy me now, and it is firmly rejected by Hunter Rawlings. A different approach to the question is needed. Nicias is not concerned with any excuses or pretexts that these deserters are offering. He is explaining the ‘true prophasis’ of this epidemic of desertion, and does so in terms of opportunity — they can find employment in the enemy's forces and there are numerous opportunities elsewhere . Translators may not want to render π' ατομολίας προάσει as ‘taking the opportunity to desert to the enemy’, arguing that ‘prophasis cannot mean opportunity’. But a prophasis is an explanation, true or false, that can be given for an action, and the best explanation can often be found in the circumstances — the opportunity that tempts or encourages. These deserters have a prophasis. This is not the only passage in Thucydides where ‘opportunity’ seems to be the word that translators need. A good example is in 4.126.5, where Brasidas is explaining how barbarian armies fight: ατοκράτωρ δ μάχη μάλιστ' ν κα πρόασιν το σᾡζεσθαί τινι πρεπόντως πορίσειε

Links

PhilArchive



    Upload a copy of this work     Papers currently archived: 90,593

External links

Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server

Through your library

Similar books and articles

The desertion of man.Earl E. Thorpe - 1958 - Baton Rouge, La.,: Ortlieb Press.
Desertion of the Alabama Troops From the Confederate Army. [REVIEW]James J. O’Brien - 1934 - Thought: Fordham University Quarterly 9 (2):329-331.
Popular ethics in ancient Greece.Lionel Pearson - 1962 - Stanford, Calif.,: Stanford University Press.
Toward a Coherent Account of Pediatric Decision Making.Ana S. Iltis - 2010 - Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 35 (5):526-552.
Hecataeus.Lionel Pearson - 1955 - The Classical Review 5 (3-4):263-.
The Alexander Romance.Lionel Pearson - 1956 - The Classical Review 6 (01):51-.
Notes on Two Passages of Strabo.Lionel Pearson - 1951 - Classical Quarterly 1 (1-2):80-.

Analytics

Added to PP
2010-12-09

Downloads
7 (#1,201,127)

6 months
4 (#319,344)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Citations of this work

No citations found.

Add more citations

References found in this work

No references found.

Add more references