Science and Education 20 (453):471 (2011)
Genes are often described by biologists using metaphors derived from computa- tional science: they are thought of as carriers of information, as being the equivalent of ‘‘blueprints’’ for the construction of organisms. Likewise, cells are often characterized as ‘‘factories’’ and organisms themselves become analogous to machines. Accordingly, when the human genome project was initially announced, the promise was that we would soon know how a human being is made, just as we know how to make airplanes and buildings. Impor- tantly, modern proponents of Intelligent Design, the latest version of creationism, have exploited biologists’ use of the language of information and blueprints to make their spurious case, based on pseudoscientific concepts such as ‘‘irreducible complexity’’ and on flawed analogies between living cells and mechanical factories. However, the living organ- ism = machine analogy was criticized already by David Hume in his Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion. In line with Hume’s criticism, over the past several years a more nuanced and accurate understanding of what genes are and how they operate has emerged, ironically in part from the work of computational scientists who take biology, and in particular developmental biology, more seriously than some biologists seem to do. In this article we connect Hume’s original criticism of the living organism = machine analogy with the modern ID movement, and illustrate how the use of misleading and outdated metaphors in science can play into the hands of pseudoscientists. Thus, we argue that dropping the blueprint and similar metaphors will improve both the science of biology and its understanding by the general public.
|Keywords||science education scientific metaphors information|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
References found in this work BETA
No references found.
Citations of this work BETA
The Mismeasure of Machine: Synthetic Biology and the Trouble with Engineering Metaphors.Maarten Boudry & Massimo Pigliucci - 2013 - Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences (4):660-668.
The Mismeasure of Machine: Synthetic Biology and the Trouble with Engineering Metaphors.Maarten Boudry & Massimo Pigliucci - 2013 - Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 44 (4):660-668.
Engineering and Biology: Counsel for a Continued Relationship.Brett Calcott, Arnon Levy, Mark L. Siegal, Orkun S. Soyer & Andreas Wagner - 2015 - Biological Theory 10 (1):50-59.
Similar books and articles
A Clash of Competing Metaphors.Michael Bradie - 1999 - Behavioral and Brain Sciences 22 (5):887-887.
Adaptive Landscapes, Phenotypic Space, and the Power of Metaphors. [REVIEW]Massimo Pigliucci - 2008 - Quarterly Review of Biology 83 (3):283-287.
Mathematical Metaphors in Natorp’s Neo-Kantian Epistemology and Philosophy of Science.Thomas Mormann - 2005 - In Falk Seeger, Johannes Lenard & Michael H. G. Hoffmann (eds.), Activity and Sign. Grounding Mathematical Education. Springer.
My Brain's Running Slow Today Â The Preference for ÂThings Ontologiesâ in Research and Everyday Discourse on Human Thinking.Roger Säljö - 2002 - Studies in Philosophy and Education 21 (4/5):389-405.
Blueprints and Recipes: Gendered Metaphors for Genetic Medicine.Celeste M. Condit - 2001 - Journal of Medical Humanities 22 (1):29-39.
Epistemological Metaphors and the Nature of Philosophy.Paul Thagard & Craig Beam - 2004 - Metaphilosophy 35 (4):504-516.
If the Genome Isn't a God-Like Ghost in the Machine, Then What is It?M. Blute - 2004 - Biology and Philosophy 20 (2-3):401-407.
Mathematical Reasoning: Analogies, Metaphors, and Images.Lyn D. English (ed.) - 1997 - L. Erlbaum Associates.
How to Confuse Organisms with Mousetraps: Machine Metaphors and Intelligent Design.Doren Recker - 2010 - Zygon 45 (3):647-664.
Cause and Effect Theories of Attention: The Role of Conceptual Metaphors.Diego Fernandez-Duque - 2002 - Review of General Psychology 6 (2):153-165.
Science Education and Moral Education.Michael Martin - 1986 - Journal of Moral Education 15 (2):99-108.
Metaphors, Models, and Mathematics in the Science of Behavior.A. Charles Catania - 2000 - Behavioral and Brain Sciences 23 (1):94-95.
Added to index2011-03-21
Total downloads791 ( #1,079 of 2,153,830 )
Recent downloads (6 months)34 ( #9,163 of 2,153,830 )
How can I increase my downloads?