An analysis of psychotherapy versus placebo studies

Behavioral and Brain Sciences 6 (2):275-285 (1983)

Abstract

Smith, Glass, and Miller have reported a meta-analysis of over 500 studies comparing some form of psychological therapy with a control condition. They report that when averaged over all dependent measures of outcome, psychological therapy is. 85 standard deviations better than the control treatment. We examined the subset of studies included in the Smith et al. metaanalysis that contained a psychotherapy and a placebo treatment. The median of the mean effect sizes for these 32 studies was. 15. There was a nonsignificant inverse relationship between mean outcome and the following: sample size, duration of therapy, use of measures of outcome other than undisguised self-report, measurement of outcome at follow-up, and use of real patients rather than subjects solicited for the purposes of participation in a research study. A qualitative analysis of the studies in terms of the type of patient involved indicates that those using psychiatric outpatients had essentially zero effect sizes and that none using psychiatric inpaticnts provide convincing evidence for psychotherapeutic effectiveness. The onty studies clearly demonstrating significant effects of psychotherapy were the ones that did not use real patients. For the most part, these studies involved small samples of subjects and brief treatments, occasionally described in quasibeliavioristic language. It was concluded that for real patients there is no evidence that the benefits of psychotherapy are greater than those of placebo treatment.

Download options

PhilArchive



    Upload a copy of this work     Papers currently archived: 72,856

External links

Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server

Through your library

Analytics

Added to PP
2014-01-20

Downloads
26 (#444,425)

6 months
1 (#386,040)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Similar books and articles

From Medicine to Psychotherapy: The Placebo Effect.Stewart Justman - 2011 - History of the Human Sciences 24 (1):95-107.
On the Impossibility of Placebo Effects in Psychotherapy.C. Wesley Demarco - 1998 - Philosophical Psychology 11 (2):207 – 227.
The Concept of Placebo.Professor Zbigniew Szawarski - 2004 - Science and Engineering Ethics 10 (1):57-64.
Is Psychotherapy Better Than a Placebo?Nathan Brody - 1984 - Behavioral and Brain Sciences 7 (4):758.
Psychotherapy Versus Placebo: An End to Polemics.Morris N. Eagle - 1983 - Behavioral and Brain Sciences 6 (2):288-289.
‘Placebos’ and the Logic of Placebo Comparison.Andrew Turner - 2012 - Biology and Philosophy 27 (3):419-432.