Philosophy Study 2 (2):115-123 (2012)
The debate concerning abortion abounds in miraculous narratives. Judith Jarvis Thomson has contrived the most celebrated set among related ones, to wit the “violinist analogy,” the “Good Samaritan” narrative, and the “Henry Fonda” allegory, by virtue of which, she intends, on the one hand, to argue that women’s right to autonomy outweighs the alleged fetus’s right to life, and on the other, to prove that no positive moral duties can be derived towards other persons alone from the fact that a moral agent is ascribed certain rights. What this short paper endeavors to prove is that Thomson’s argumentation by analogy is a weak one, since neither the number nor the relevance of similarities invoked is adequate or satisfactory, while crucial parameters concerning the morality of abortion are being totally overlooked.
|Keywords||abortion, fetus, rape, violinist analogy, Good Samaritan, duty, right, morality|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
References found in this work BETA
No references found.
Citations of this work BETA
No citations found.
Similar books and articles
Personhood, Property Rights, and the Permissibility of Abortion.Paul A. Roth - 1983 - Law and Philosophy 2 (2):163 - 191.
Creation and Abortion: A Study in Moral and Legal Philosophy.F. M. Kamm - 1992 - Oxford University Press.
Abortion and Degrees of Personhood: Understanding the Impasse of the Abortion Problem.Hon-Lam Li - 1997 - Public Affairs Quarterly 11 (1):1-19.
How to Understand a Woman's Obligations to the Fetus in Unwanted Pregnancies.Kristen Hine - 2013 - Journal of Bioethical Inquiry 10 (2):239-247.
Abortion and Virtue Ethics.Mathew Lu - 2011 - In Stephen Napier (ed.), Persons, Moral Worth, and Embryos: A Critical Analysis of Pro-Choice Arguments. Springer.
Who Needs the ’Actual Future Principle’?: Harman on Abortion.Nathan Nobis - 2002 - Southwest Philosophy Review 18 (2):55-63.
Abortion, Society, and the Law.David F. Walbert - 1973 - Cleveland [Ohio]Press of Case Western Reserve University.
Defending Abortion Philosophically: A Review of David Boonin's a Defense of Abortion. [REVIEW]Francis J. Beckwith - 2006 - Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 31 (2):177 – 203.
Intercourse and Moral Responsibility for the Fetus.Holly M. Smith - 1983 - In William B. Bondesson, H. Tristram Englehardt, Stuart Spicker & Daniel H. Winship (eds.), Abortion and the Status of the Fetus. D. Reidel.
Added to index2013-02-05
Total downloads172 ( #25,498 of 2,152,647 )
Recent downloads (6 months)24 ( #14,709 of 2,152,647 )
How can I increase my downloads?