Comparison of group counseling with individual counseling in the comprehension of informed consent: a randomized controlled trial
Rajiv Sarkar, Thuppal V. Sowmyanarayanan, Prasanna Samuel, Azara S. Singh, Anuradha Bose, Jayaprakash Muliyil & Gagandeep Kang
BMC Medical Ethics 11 (1):8- (2010)
AbstractBackgroundStudies on different methods to supplement the traditional informed consent process have generated conflicting results. This study was designed to evaluate whether participants who received group counseling prior to administration of informed consent understood the key components of the study and the consent better than those who received individual counseling, based on the hypothesis that group counseling would foster discussion among potential participants and enhance their understanding of the informed consent.MethodsParents of children participating in a trial of nutritional supplementation were randomized to receive either group counseling or individual counseling prior to administration of the informed consent. To assess the participant's comprehension, a structured questionnaire was administered approximately 48-72 hours afterwards by interviewers who were blinded to the allocation group of the respondents.ResultsA total of 128 parents were recruited and follow up was established with 118 (90.2%) for the study. All respondents were aware of their child's participation in a research study and the details of sample collection. However, their understanding of study purpose, randomization and withdrawal was poor. There was no difference in comprehension of key elements of the informed consent between the intervention and control arm.ConclusionsThe results suggest that the group counseling might not influence the overall comprehension of the informed consent process. Further research is required to devise better ways of improving participants' understanding of randomization in clinical trials.Trial RegistrationClinical Trial Registry - India (CTRI): CTRI/2009/091/000612
Similar books and articles
Taking the Group Seriously: Towards a Post-Foulkesian Group Analytic Theory.Farhad Dalal - 1998 - J. Kingsley.
Enhancing clinician provision of informed consent and counseling: Some pedagogical strategies.Stephen Wear - 1999 - Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 24 (1):34 – 42.
Routine screening: Informed consent, stigma and the waning of HIV exceptionalism.Matthew K. Wynia - 2006 - American Journal of Bioethics 6 (4):5 – 8.
The conflict between ethics and business in community pharmacy: What about patient counseling? [REVIEW]David B. Resnik, Paul L. Ranelli & Susan P. Resnik - 2000 - Journal of Business Ethics 28 (2):179 - 186.
Informed consent and the misattributed paternity problem in genetic counseling.Erica K. Lucast - 2007 - Bioethics 21 (1):41–50.
Philosophy Practice: An Alternative to Counseling and Psychotherapy.Shlomit C. Schuster - 1999 - Praeger.
Individual autonomy and the double-blind controlled experiment: The case of desperate volunteers.N. Waller Bruce - 1995 - Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 20 (1).
Comprehension and Recall of Informed Consent among Participating Families in a Birth Cohort Study on Diarrhoeal Disease.R. Sarkar, E. W. Grandin, B. P. Gladstone, J. Muliyil & G. Kang - 2009 - Public Health Ethics 2 (1):37-44.
Decision-making through dialogue: Reconfiguring autonomy in genetic counseling. [REVIEW]Mary Terrell White - 1998 - Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics 19 (1):5-19.
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads
Citations of this work
Improving understanding in the research informed consent process: a systematic review of 54 interventions tested in randomized control trials. [REVIEW]Adam Nishimura, Jantey Carey, Patricia J. Erwin, Jon C. Tilburt, M. Hassan Murad & Jennifer B. McCormick - 2013 - BMC Medical Ethics 14 (1):28.
Bioethical reflexivity and requirements of valid consent: conceptual tools.John Barugahare - 2019 - BMC Medical Ethics 20 (1):44.
A qualitative study on aspects of consent for genomic research in communities with low literacy.Daima Bukini, Columba Mbekenga, Siana Nkya, Lisa Purvis, Sheryl McCurdy, Michael Parker & Julie Makani - 2020 - BMC Medical Ethics 21 (1):1-7.
Experiences and practices of key research team members in obtaining informed consent for pharmacogenetic research among people living with HIV: a qualitative study.Nabukenya Sylvia, Ochieng Joseph, Kaawa-Mafigiri David, Munabi Ian, Nakigudde Janet, Nakwagala Frederick Nelson, Barugahare John, Kwagala Betty, Ibingira Charles, Twimwijukye Adelline, Sewankambo Nelson & Mwaka Erisa Sabakaki - 2022 - Research Ethics 18 (3):193-209.
References found in this work
Informed consent in Ghana: what do participants really understand?Z. Hill, C. Tawiah-Agyemang, S. Odei-Danso & B. Kirkwood - 2008 - Journal of Medical Ethics 34 (1):48-53.
Evaluation of the quality of informed consent in a vaccine field trial in a developing country setting.Deon Minnies, Tony Hawkridge, Willem Hanekom, Rodney Ehrlich, Leslie London & Greg Hussey - 2008 - BMC Medical Ethics 9 (1):15-.
Understanding and retention of the informed consent process among parents in rural northern Ghana.Abraham R. Oduro, Raymond A. Aborigo, Dickson Amugsi, Francis Anto, Thomas Anyorigiya, Frank Atuguba, Abraham Hodgson & Kwadwo A. Koram - 2008 - BMC Medical Ethics 9 (1):12-.