Trial by slogan: Natural law and Lex iniusta non est Lex [Book Review]
Law and Philosophy 19 (4):433 - 449 (2000)
Norman Kretzmann''s recent analysis of the natural lawslogan ``lex iniusta non est lex'''' (an unjust law is nota law) demonstrates the coherence of the slogan andmakes a case for its practical value, but I shallargue that it also ends up showing that the sloganfails to mark any interesting conceptual or practicaldivision between natural law and legal positivistviews about the nature of law. I argue that this is ahappy result. The non-est-lex slogan has been used toexaggerate the extent of disagreement about the natureof law and has diverted critics of natural law theoryfrom recognizing that the main disagreement betweennatural lawyers and legal positivists centres ontheories of practical reason and how they affect ourunderstanding of the relationship between law andmorality. This extends the debate about the nature oflaw somewhat beyond the traditional boundaries ofphilosophy of law, but these boundaries are due inpart to the diversion created by debate over thenon-est-lex slogan. Recognizing that the non-est-lexslogan fails on its own to mark any interestingpractical or conceptual division between natural lawtheories and legal positivism should therefore focusand encourage debate on matters of genuine substancebetween these outlooks. The disagreement, however, mayturn out to be primarily metaphysical and explanatoryand not normative in nature.
|Keywords||Law Logic Philosophy of Law Law Theory/Law Philosophy Political Science Social Issues|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
References found in this work BETA
No references found.
Citations of this work BETA
Limitations of the Sport-Law Comparison.J. S. Russell - 2011 - Journal of the Philosophy of Sport 38 (2):254-272.
Similar books and articles
Narrative, Nature, and the Natural Law: From Aquinas to International Human Rights.C. Fred Alford - 2010 - Palgrave-Macmillan.
Naturgesetz, Selbstbestimmung und Moralität. Thomas von Aquin und die Begründung einer zeitgemässen Ethik.Matthias Perkams - 2008 - Studia Neoaristotelica 5 (2):109-131.
The Natural Moral Law: The Good After Modernity.Owen J. Anderson - 2012 - Cambridge University Press.
The Lex Permissiva and the Source of Natural Right in Kant's Metaphysics of Morals and Fichte's Foundations of Natural Right.Murray Skees - 2009 - International Philosophical Quarterly 49 (3):375-398.
Natural Law, Religion, and Rights: An Exploration of the Relationship Between Natural Law and Natural Rights, with Special Emphasis on the Teachings of Thomas Hobbes and John Locke.Henrik Syse - 2007 - St. Augustine's Press.
God and the Natural Law: A Rereading of Thomas Aquinas.Fulvio Di Blasi - 2006 - St. Augustine's Press.
Trial by Slogan: Natural Law and Lex Iniusta Non Est Lex.S. J. - 2000 - Law and Philosophy 19 (4):433-449.
Added to index2009-01-28
Total downloads16 ( #292,318 of 2,152,239 )
Recent downloads (6 months)2 ( #281,219 of 2,152,239 )
How can I increase my downloads?