The Second-Class Citizen in Legal Theory

Modern Law Review (2023)
  Copy   BIBTEX


This essay is a critical notice of David Dyzenhaus's book, The Long Arc of Legality. I argue that Dyzenhaus’s criterion for distinguishing legal pathologies that undermine law's contractarian claim to legitimacy and political pathologies that do not is unsustainable. It relies on a categorical distinction between the threat to law's legitimacy posed by treating some subjects as de jure second-class citizens, whose formal legal status is compromised, and other threats to political legitimacy grounded in the treatment of some subjects as de facto second-class citizens, who retain full formal legal equality but suffer from thoroughgoing substantive subordination. But some forms of de facto second-class citizenship are a greater threat to contractarian legitimacy than some forms of full formal equality. So formal equality for subjects and legal legitimacy come apart. I consider and respond to several responses on Dyzenhaus's behalf, and conclude by proposing a version of his jurisprudential theory that relaxes this distinction.



External links

Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server

Through your library

Similar books and articles

Citizenship and Patriotism.Polycarp Ikuenobe - 2010 - Public Affairs Quarterly 24 (4):297-318.
Marxist theory of law.Alan Hunt - 1996 - In Dennis Patterson (ed.), A Companion to Philosophy of Law and Legal Theory. Oxford, UK: Blackwell. pp. 350–360.
Critical legal theory.Mark V. Tushnet - 2004 - In Martin P. Golding & William A. Edmundson (eds.), The Blackwell Guide to the Philosophy of Law and Legal Theory. Oxford, UK: Blackwell. pp. 80--89.
Legality's Borders: An Essay in General Jurisprudence.Keith Charles Culver - 2010 - Oxford University Press. Edited by Michael Giudice.
Legal Modes and Democratic Citizens in Republican Theory.Galya Benarieh Ruffer - 2013 - In Andreas Niederberger & Philipp Schink (eds.), Republican democracy: liberty, law and politics. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
Hermann Heller and the legitimacy of legality.Dyzenhaus David - 1996 - Oxford Journal of Legal Studies 16 (4).


Added to PP

171 (#114,325)

6 months
136 (#27,586)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author's Profile

Jack Samuel
New York University

Citations of this work

No citations found.

Add more citations

References found in this work

Persons and bodies.Japa Pallikkathayil - 2017 - In Sari Kisilevsky & Martin Jay Stone (eds.), Freedom and Force: Essays on Kant’s Legal Philosophy. Bloomsbury Academic. pp. 35-54.

Add more references