Does Macbeth See a Dagger? An Empirical Argument for the Existence-Neutrality of Seeing

Erkenntnis:1-24 (forthcoming)
  Copy   BIBTEX

Abstract

In a recent paper, Justin D’Ambrosio (2020) has offered an empirical argument in support of a negative solution to the puzzle of Macbeth’s dagger—namely, the question of whether, in the famous scene from Shakespeare’s play, Macbeth sees a dagger in front of him. D’Ambrosio’s strategy consists in showing that “seeing” is not an existence-neutral verb; that is, that the way it is used in ordinary language is not neutral with respect to whether its complement exists. In this paper, we offer an empirical argument in favor of an existence-neutral reading of “seeing”. In particular, we argue that existence-neutral readings are readily available to language users. We thus call into question D’Ambrosio’s argument for the claim that Macbeth does not see a dagger. According to our positive solution, Macbeth sees a dagger, even though there is not a dagger in front of him.

Similar books and articles

Hallucinating real things.Steven P. James - 2014 - Synthese 191 (15):3711-3732.
Despairing Macbeth: A Speech Out of Place.William Irwin - 2019 - Philosophy and Literature 43 (1):1-10.
God, God* and God'.Graham Oppy - 2004 - In Anthony Fisher & Hayden Ramsay (eds.), Faith and Reason: Friends or Foes in a New Millennium? Hindmarsh, South Australia: ATF Press. pp. 171-186.
Dagger Categories of Tame Relations.Bart Jacobs - 2013 - Logica Universalis 7 (3):341-370.
Π12 Wadge degrees.Greg Hjorth - 1996 - Annals of Pure and Applied Logic 77 (1):53-74.

Analytics

Added to PP
2021-04-10

Downloads
280 (#43,493)

6 months
65 (#19,088)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author Profiles

Vilius Dranseika
Jagiellonian University
André Sant'Anna
University of Cologne

Citations of this work

No citations found.

Add more citations

References found in this work

Reference and Consciousness.J. Campbell - 2002 - Oxford University Press.
Sense and Sensibilia.John Langshaw Austin - 1962 - Oxford University Press.
Perception and Its Objects.Bill Brewer - 2011 - Oxford University Press.
Seeing And Knowing.Fred I. Dretske - 1969 - Chicago: University Of Chicago Press.

View all 21 references / Add more references