Sidgwick's Axioms and Consequentialism

Philosophical Review 123 (2):173-204 (2014)
Abstract
Sidgwick gives various tests for highest certainty. When he applies these tests to commonsense morality, he finds nothing of highest certainty. In contrast, when he applies these tests to his own axioms, he finds these axioms to have highest certainty. The axioms culminate in Benevolence: “Each one is morally bound to regard the good of any other individual as much as his own, except in so far as he judges it to be less, when impartially viewed, or less certainly knowable or attainable by him.” The axioms face challenges from two sides.First, one test requires that a claim not be denied by someone of whom one has no more reason to suspect of error than oneself. For Sidgwick, then, the egoist must not deny the axioms. But it would seem that an egoist would reject benevolence. Second, Sidgwick thinks he must show that the commonsense moralist agrees to the axioms. Benevolence seems to say that the only reason for departing from being bound to treat others like oneself is that more good would be produced. But the commonsense moralist will not agree that this is the only reason. In reply to the threat of an egoist's disagreement, this essay argues that many of the axioms should be read as having as their antecedent “from the point of view of the universe.” The essay replies to the objection that this makes these axioms analytic. In reply to the threat of a commonsense moralist's disagreement, this essay argues that each axiom states, in effect, a prima facie duty. The argument against the commonsense moralist concerns not benevolence but whether there are further duties that pass the tests. The essay raises the worry that here Sidgwick is unfair since sometimes he criticizes all-things-considered versions of commonsense duties; such criticisms would count against benevolence as well
Keywords No keywords specified (fix it)
Categories (categorize this paper)
DOI 10.1215/00318108-2315306
Options
 Save to my reading list
Follow the author(s)
Edit this record
My bibliography
Export citation
Find it on Scholar
Mark as duplicate
Request removal from index
Revision history
Download options
Our Archive


Upload a copy of this paper     Check publisher's policy     Papers currently archived: 30,727
External links

Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server
Configure custom proxy (use this if your affiliation does not provide a proxy)
Through your library
References found in this work BETA
Henry Sidgwick's Moral Epistemology.Anthony Skelton - 2010 - Journal of the History of Philosophy 48 (4):491-519.
Utilitarian Practical Ethics: Sidgwick and Singer.Anthony Skelton - 2011 - In Placido Bucolo, Roger Crisp & Bart Schultz (eds.), Henry Sidgwick: Ethics, Psychics, and Politics. Catania: University of Catania Press.
Sidgwick's Philosophical Intuitions.Anthony Skelton - 2008 - Etica and Politica / Ethics & Politics 10 (2):185-209.

Add more references

Citations of this work BETA
On the Utility of Religious Toleration.Frederick Schauer - 2016 - Criminal Law and Philosophy 10 (3):479-492.

Add more citations

Similar books and articles
Utilitarianism and Egoism in Sidgwickian Ethics.Robert Shaver - 2013 - Revue D’Études Benthamiennes 12.
On Extremal Axioms.Rudolf Carnap, Friedrich Bachmann & H. G. Bohnert - 1981 - History and Philosophy of Logic 2 (1-2):67-85.
Sidgwick's Philosophical Intuitions.Anthony Skelton - 2008 - Etica and Politica / Ethics & Politics 10 (2):185-209.
Measurement Without Archimedean Axioms.Louis Narens - 1974 - Philosophy of Science 41 (4):374-393.
Axioms in Mathematical Practice.D. Schlimm - 2013 - Philosophia Mathematica 21 (1):37-92.
Forcing Indestructibility of Set-Theoretic Axioms.Bernhard König - 2007 - Journal of Symbolic Logic 72 (1):349 - 360.
Applied Axioms.Alfred Sidgwick - 1905 - Mind 14 (53):42-57.
Mr. Bode's Review of `Applied Axioms'.Alfred Sidgwick - 1905 - Journal of Philosophy, Psychology and Scientific Methods 2 (10):268-269.
Added to PP index
2014-04-25

Total downloads
25 ( #209,989 of 2,197,335 )

Recent downloads (6 months)
4 ( #61,579 of 2,197,335 )

How can I increase my downloads?

Monthly downloads
My notes
Sign in to use this feature