A Critical Examination of the AICPA’s New “Conceptual Framework” Ethics Protocol
Journal of Business Ethics 155 (4):1135-1152 (2019)
Abstract
What does it look like when an organization tentatively steps away from an exclusively rules-based regime and begins to attend to both rules and principles? What insights and guidance can ethicists and ethical theory offer? This paper is a case study of an organization that has initiated such a transition. The American Institute of Certified Public Accountants has begun a turn toward the promotion of ethical principles and best practices by adding a “conceptual framework” to its existing Code of Professional Conduct. This conceptual framework calls upon its members to intentionally increase their awareness of significant threats to their compliance with its rules of conduct and to establish safeguards to offset or eliminate those threats. To this end, each member is required to regard every questionable situation, circumstance, transaction or relationship by attempting to view it through the eyes of an imagined reasonable third party. This paper examines this protocol theoretically and practically. First, we frame this analysis within the principles and ethical concepts that inform the professional ethics of accountants. Second, we critique the AICPA’s long-standing rules-based approach to its Code. Third, we examine the new conceptual framework with a view toward its potential for the promotion of a more principles-based approach to the professional ethics of the accounting profession. Fourth, we give attention to the notion of the “reasonable and informed third party,” which has been embedded in the new conceptual framework, and consider how two schools of thought—Adam Smith’s modernist “impartial spectator” concept and Emmanuel Lévinas’ postmodern phenomenology in regard to “the Other”—may offer theoretical support and clarity for this epistemic exercise. Finally, we point out several ways in which the AICPA’s commitment to its new conceptual framework could be strengthened and enhanced.Author's Profile
My notes
Similar books and articles
It’s Time for Principles-Based Accounting Ethics.Albert D. Spalding & Alfonso Oddo - 2011 - Journal of Business Ethics 99 (S1):49-59.
It's Time for Principles-Based Accounting Ethics.Albert D. Spalding Jr & Alfonso Oddo - 2011 - Journal of Business Ethics 99 (S1):49 - 59.
Ethical Principles vs. Ethical Rules: The Moderating Effect of Moral Development on Audit Independence Judgments.Terri L. Herron & David L. Gilbertson - 2004 - Business Ethics Quarterly 14 (3):499-523.
Ethical Principles vs. Ethical Rules: The Moderating Effect of Moral Development on Audit Independence Judgments.Terri L. Herron & David L. Gilbertson - 2004 - Business Ethics Quarterly 14 (3):499-523.
A critical examination of the AICPA code of professional conduct.Allison Collins & Norm Schultz - 1995 - Journal of Business Ethics 14 (1):31 - 41.
Deficiencies in the Code of Conduct: The AICPA Rhetoric Surrounding the Tax Return Preparation Outsourcing Disclosure Rules. [REVIEW]Renu Desai & Robin Roberts - 2013 - Journal of Business Ethics 114 (3):457-471.
Professional ethics code conflict situations: Ethical and value orientation of collegiate accounting students. [REVIEW]Irene N. McCarthy - 1997 - Journal of Business Ethics 16 (12-13):1467-1473.
Ethics and the Auditing Culture: Rethinking the Foundation of Accounting and Auditing.David Satava, Cam Caldwell & Linda Richards - 2006 - Journal of Business Ethics 64 (3):271-284.
In Support of Public or Private Interests? An Examination of Sanctions Imposed Under the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct.J. Gregory Jenkins, Velina Popova & Mark D. Sheldon - 2018 - Journal of Business Ethics 152 (2):523-549.
Framing Ethical Acceptability: A Problem with Nuclear Waste in Canada.Ethan T. Wilding - 2012 - Science and Engineering Ethics 18 (2):301-313.
Regulatory Enforcement of Accounting Ethics in Puerto Rico.Rogelio J. Cardona, Zabihollah Rezaee, Wanda Rivera-Ortiz & José C. Vega-Vilca - 2020 - Journal of Business Ethics 167 (1):63-76.
Possible ethical issues and their impact on the firm: Perceptions held by public accountants. [REVIEW]Jeanne M. David, Jeffrey Kantor & Ira Greenberg - 1994 - Journal of Business Ethics 13 (12):919 - 937.
Influencing ethical development: Exposing students to the AICPA code of conduct. [REVIEW]Sharon Green & James Weber - 1997 - Journal of Business Ethics 16 (8):777-790.
Professional Accountants’ Identity Formation: An Integrative Framework.François Brouard, Merridee Bujaki, Sylvain Durocher & Leighann C. Neilson - 2017 - Journal of Business Ethics 142 (2):225-238.
Ethical Decision Making and Reputation Management in Public Relations.Yanick Farmer - 2018 - Journal of Media Ethics 33 (1):2-13.
Analytics
Added to PP
2019-04-08
Downloads
14 (#733,349)
6 months
1 (#451,971)
2019-04-08
Downloads
14 (#733,349)
6 months
1 (#451,971)
Historical graph of downloads
Author's Profile
Citations of this work
The Influence of Ethical Codes of Conduct on Professionalism in Tax Practice.Darius Fatemi, John Hasseldine & Peggy Hite - 2020 - Journal of Business Ethics 164 (1):133-149.
References found in this work
Non‐Relative Virtues: An Aristotelian Approach.Martha C. Nussbaum - 1988 - Midwest Studies in Philosophy 13 (1):32-53.
Managerial Work in a Practice-Embodying Institution: The Role of Calling, The Virtue of Constancy. [REVIEW]Ron Beadle - 2013 - Journal of Business Ethics 113 (4):679-690.