Roczniki Filozoficzne 69 (1):119-138 (2021)

This paper consists of my responses to the comments by nine commentators on my book Are we Bodies or Souls? It makes twelve separate points, each one relevant to the comments of one or more of the commentators, as follows: I defend my understanding of “knowing the essence” of an object as knowing a set of logically necessary and sufficient conditions for an object to be that object; I claim that there cannot be thoughts without a thinker; I argue that my distinction of “mental” from “physical” events in terms of whether anyone has privileged access to whether or not they occur, is a clear one; and I defend my account of metaphysical modality and its role in defending my account of personal identity; I defend my view that Descartes’s argument in favor of the view that humans are essentially souls fails, but that my amended version of that argument succeeds; I claim that my theory acknowledges the closeness of the connection in an earthly life between a human soul and its body; I argue that my Cartesian theory of the soul-body relation is preferable to Aquinas’s theory of that; I argue that a material thing cannot have mental properties; I argue that any set of logically necessary conditions for an object to be the object it is, which together form a logically sufficient condition for this, mutually entails any other such set; I deny that a dualist needs to provide an explanation of how the soul has the capacities that it has; and finally I defend my view that souls have thisness, and claim that that is not a difficulty for the view that God determines which persons will exist.
Keywords No keywords specified (fix it)
Categories No categories specified
(categorize this paper)
DOI 10.18290/rf21691-11
Edit this record
Mark as duplicate
Export citation
Find it on Scholar
Request removal from index
Revision history

Download options

PhilArchive copy

Upload a copy of this paper     Check publisher's policy     Papers currently archived: 64,229
External links

Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server
Configure custom proxy (use this if your affiliation does not provide a proxy)
Through your library

References found in this work BETA

Essence and Modality.Kit Fine - 1994 - Philosophical Perspectives 8 (Logic and Language):1-16.
Does Conceivability Entail Possibility.David Chalmers - 2002 - In Tamar Szabo Gendler & John Hawthorne (eds.), Conceivability and Possibility. Oxford University Press. pp. 145--200.

Add more references

Citations of this work BETA

No citations found.

Add more citations

Similar books and articles

A Dilemma for the Soul Theory of Personal Identity.Jacob Berger - 2018 - International Journal for Philosophy of Religion 83 (1):41-55.
Swinburne’s Are We Bodies or Souls?William Hasker - 2021 - Roczniki Filozoficzne 69 (1):67-82.
Conceptualizing the ‘Female’ Soul – a Study in Plato and Proclus.Jana Schultz - 2019 - British Journal for the History of Philosophy 27 (5):883-901.
St. Thomas Aquinas on Punishing Souls.Patrick Toner - 2012 - International Journal for Philosophy of Religion 71 (2):103-116.
How Are Souls Related to Bodies? A Study of John Buridan.Jack Zupko - 1993 - Review of Metaphysics 46 (3):575 - 601.
What Could Pair a Nonphysical Soul to a Physical Body?Jaegwon Kim - 2015 - In Keith Augustine & Michael Martin (eds.), The Myth of an Afterlife: The Case against Life After Death. Rowman & Littlefield. pp. 335-347.
Summary of Are We Bodies or Souls?Richard Swinburne - 2021 - Roczniki Filozoficzne 69 (1):7-10.
Kant's Earliest Solution to the Mind/Body Problem.Andrew Norris Carpenter - 1998 - Dissertation, University of California, Berkeley
There is No Trace of Any Soul Linked to the Body.David Papineau - 2015 - In Keith Augustine & Michael Martin (eds.), The Myth of an Afterlife: The Case against Life After Death. Rowman & Littlefield. pp. 369-376.
Imagination and Memory in Marsilio Ficino’s Theory of the Vehicles of the Soul 1.Anna Corrias - 2012 - International Journal of the Platonic Tradition 6 (1):81-114.
Surviving Souls.Paul Moser & Arnold Vander Nat - 1993 - Canadian Journal of Philosophy 23 (1):101-106.


Added to PP index

Total views
8 ( #983,680 of 2,455,424 )

Recent downloads (6 months)
2 ( #303,315 of 2,455,424 )

How can I increase my downloads?


My notes