Philosophy East and West 54 (2):143-170 (2004)
: Claus Oetke, in his "Ancient Indian Logic as a Theory of Non-monotonic Reasoning," presents a sweeping new interpretation of the early history of Indian logic. His main proposal is that Indian logic up until Dharmakirti was nonmonotonic in character-similar to some of the newer logics that have been explored in the field of Artificial Intelligence, such as default logic, which abandon deductive validity as a requirement for formally acceptable arguments; Dharmakirti, he suggests, was the first to consider that a good argument should be one for which it is not possible for the property identified as the "reason" (hetu) to occur without the property to be proved (sadhya)-a requirement akin to deductive validity. Oetke's approach is challenged here, arguing that from the very beginning in India something like monotonic, that is, deductively valid, reasoning was the ideal or norm, but that the conception of that ideal was continually refined, in that the criteria for determining when it is realized were progressively sharpened
|Keywords||No keywords specified (fix it)|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
References found in this work BETA
No references found.
Citations of this work BETA
History, Philology, and the Philosophical Study of Sanskrit Texts.Parimal G. Patil - 2010 - Journal of Indian Philosophy 38 (2):163-202.
Some Issues of Scholarly Exegesis (in Indian Philosophy).Claus Oetke - 2009 - Journal of Indian Philosophy 37 (5):415-497.
Similar books and articles
Two Approaches to the Formalisation of Defeasible Deontic Reasoning.Henry Prakken - 1996 - Studia Logica 57 (1):73 - 90.
Nonmonotonic Reasoning: Logical Foundations of Commonsense.Gerhard Brewka (ed.) - 1991 - Cambridge University Press.
Place of Logic in Indian Philosophy.Desh Raj Sirswal - 2015 - Lokayata: Journal of Positive Philosophy 2:39-49.
Efficient Reasoning About Rich Temporal Domains.Yoav Shoham - 1988 - Journal of Philosophical Logic 17 (4):443 - 474.
Ancient Indian Logic as a Theory of Non-Monotonic Reasoning.Claus Oetke - 1996 - Journal of Indian Philosophy 24 (5):447-539.
Added to index2009-01-28
Total downloads226 ( #16,308 of 2,163,853 )
Recent downloads (6 months)1 ( #348,100 of 2,163,853 )
How can I increase my downloads?