Save Us From Being Saved: Girard's Critical Soteriology

Contagion: Journal of Violence, Mimesis, and Culture 12 (1):21-30 (2005)
  Copy   BIBTEX

Abstract

In lieu of an abstract, here is a brief excerpt of the content:Save Us From Being Saved:Girard's Critical SoteriologySimon J. Taylor (bio)One of the most striking things about the work of René Girard is that it is an overarching critique of what it is to be saved. The paradox that Girard presents us with is that "salvation" is something from which we must be saved. This combination of salvation as something that must be avoided and something we desperately need appears to have the characteristic of a "double bind," about which Girard has written so much.1 Are we then, even within Girard's own thesis, bound to the mimetic doubling of need and revulsion that can end only in the expulsion or death of a common victim? It is this question that I hope to explore in this article.Girard's Critique Of SalvationTo set out Girard's critique of salvation, it is first necessary to see that what he has come to call the victimage mechanism ("mécanisme victimaire") is, in fact, salvation. Girard's thesis states that desire is mimetic, based on the imitation of another's desire. "Desire is always an imitation of another desire, desire for the same object, and therefore, an inexhaustible source of conflicts and rivalries" (Girard 1978, 39). As the rivalry produced by this desire intensifies, it spreads and produces conflict and violence on a large scale. On an unlimited scale, Girard identifies this with the Hobbesian "war of all against all."2 And it is at this point that the victimage mechanism kicks in. It is at this point that the identification of a scapegoat and the expulsion or killing of the scapegoat produce unity and restore peace. It is this, in Girard's originary scene, that leads to the simultaneous origins of society and religion. In restoring unity to the group, and hence founding the community, the victim becomes sacred, a god. This in itself is an indicator of the salvific power that the scapegoat effects in the community. In order that the violence, once diverted, should not break out again, two things are necessary: ritual, specifically sacrifice, and myth. Ritual reenacts the founding murder upon which society is based, enabling the [End Page 21] participants to transfer their violence to another victim. Myth is the story told by the persecutors about the events that led to the creation of their community, that is, the founding murder. Thus, religion "dehumanizes violence; it protects man from his own violence by taking it out of his hands, transforming it into a transcendent and ever-present danger to be kept in check by the appropriate rites appropriately observed and by a modest and prudent demeanor.... religion protects man as long as its ultimate foundations are not revealed" (Girard 1978, 134–35). Salvation has happened, and a cult arises to disburse the effects of this salvation.It is important that we take this account of religion with full seriousness and do not regard it simply as the prologue to Girard's later promotion, even rehabilitation, of the Judaeo-Christian tradition. This is salvific: religion protects us from our own violence; it has mechanisms for bringing to an end outbreaks of that violence. Elsewhere Girard can speak of "the negative usefulness of religion as a social prop against anarchy and chaos" (Girard 1997, 162–63). This is salvation: violence is dealt with and human society can dwell in relative peace. Religion, on this account, is not "pie-in-the-sky," a transcendent deferral of gratification. It has real benefits to society today; it is attractive, elegant, and simple. What more could we want from religion?But Girard will not allow us to rest content with this account of religion. He is blunt when he declares that "most religions are based on a lie, which is the supposed guilt of the victim" (Girard 1993c, 32). Nietzsche wrote that "The sacrificial animal does not share the spectators' ideas about sacrifice, but one has never let it have its say,"3 and this is precisely the origin of Girard's critique of the salvation offered by religions based on scapegoating. Girard is attempting to let the sacrificial animal have its say. All too often, these...

Other Versions

No versions found

Links

PhilArchive



    Upload a copy of this work     Papers currently archived: 97,319

External links

Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server

Through your library

Similar books and articles

Mimetic Theories of Religion and Violence.Wolfgang Palaver - 2013 - The Oxford Handbook of Religion and Violence:533-553.
René Girard and Giorgio Agamben.Bart Leenman - 2024 - Contagion: Journal of Violence, Mimesis, and Culture 31 (1):203-225.
René Girard and the Deferral of Violence.Eric Gans - 2018 - Forum Philosophicum: International Journal for Philosophy 23 (2):155-170.
Violence, Resistance, and Reconciliation: A Mimetic Analysis of East Timorese Storytelling.Joel Hodge - 2011 - Contagion: Journal of Violence, Mimesis, and Culture 18 (1):71-92.
The Neurology of Culture, or How We Move From Rage to Ritual in the Process of Hominization.Gregory J. Lobo - 2024 - Contagion: Journal of Violence, Mimesis, and Culture 31 (1):255-273.
René girards absolute theorie.A. Vergote - 1996 - Tijdschrift Voor Filosofie 58 (1):128 - 141.
Señor Hirsch as Sacrificial Victim and the Modernism of Conrad's Nostromo.Andrew Bartlett - 1997 - Contagion: Journal of Violence, Mimesis, and Culture 4 (1):47-66.
A Girardian Critique of the Liberal Democratic Peace Theory.Kyle Scott - 2008 - Contagion: Journal of Violence, Mimesis, and Culture 15:45-62.
BOSKA PRZEMOC. WOKÓŁ KOZŁA OFIARNEGO RENÉ GIRARDA.Grzegorz Wiończyk - 2014 - Hybris, Revista de Filosofí­A (26):087-105.

Analytics

Added to PP
2024-01-21

Downloads
7 (#1,578,329)

6 months
6 (#1,113,498)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author's Profile

Simon Taylor
University of Manchester

Citations of this work

No citations found.

Add more citations

References found in this work

No references found.

Add more references