Heythrop Journal 60:413-435 (2019)

Authors
Lucas Thorpe
Bogazici University
Abstract
In this paper I focus on the work of Sayyid Qutb and in particular his book Milestones, which is often regarded as the Communist Manifesto of Islamic fundamentalism. This paper has four main sections. First I outline Qutb’s political position and in particular examine his advocacy of offensive jihad. In section two I argue that there are a number of tendencies that make his position potentially more liberal that it is often taken to be. I here argue that there are at least six reasons why Qutb’s position is not intrinsically as anti-liberal as it might at first appear. First, many western liberals, influenced by the social contract tradition, regard the legitimacy of their societies as based on popular sovereignty. Qutb, however, regards a society based on popular sovereignty, where law emerges from the will of man rather than the will of God, as a form of tyranny, so it would seem that he is in principle opposed to Western liberal societies. It is not clear, however, that we, or Islamic fundamentalist, need to regard Western liberal societies as based on popular sovereignty, for it is always possible to interpret Western political institutions through the lens of natural law theory, which was one of the main sources of the liberal tradition. In this section I will compare Qutb’s political philosophy with that of Aquinas to illustrate this point and suggest the possibility of secularists and puritan Islamists being able to form an overlapping consensus on the legitimacy of liberal Western societies. Secondly, there is an analogue to the social contract in Qutb’s own position as he believes that legitimate authority requires the free submission of the governed. Thirdly, Qutb is in principle a fallibilist about human reason; this fallibilism extends even to our capacity to interpret divine revelation. Fourthly, Islamic universalism requires that Muslims regard enemies they might be fighting as potential converts. Fifthly, Qutb, like most Sunni fundamentalists, is an implacable enemy of theocracy. And finally, Qutb is a gradualist. In the third section I argue that the real danger for liberal societies from believers in a position like Qutb’s is sociological rather than intrinsic to the ideology – specifically, that there is a danger that such groups may develop in a ‘Leninist’ direction. In the final section I argue that one of the main reasons for this danger is the lack of a consensus in the Islamic world about what it is to be a good, or even a true, Muslim, and that the slow emergence of some sort of consensus will require a vigorous public debate amongst Muslims. Western liberals should welcome such debate rather than fearing such, and should do all they can to ensure that civil society, both in Western societies and in predominantly Islamic societies, is open to such debate.
Keywords Qutb  Aquinas  Liberalism  Natural Law  Islamic Political Philosophy  Political Philosophy  Kant  pluralism
Categories (categorize this paper)
Reprint years 2015, 2016, 2017, 2019
DOI 10.1111/heyj.12256
Options
Edit this record
Mark as duplicate
Export citation
Find it on Scholar
Request removal from index
Revision history

Download options

References found in this work BETA

8 On Rawls and Political Liberalism1.Burton Dreben - 2003 - In Samuel Richard Freeman (ed.), The Cambridge Companion to Rawls. Cambridge University Press. pp. 316.
Basic Principles of the Islamic Worldview.Sayyid Quṭb - 2006 - Islamic Publications International.

Add more references

Citations of this work BETA

No citations found.

Add more citations

Similar books and articles

Al-Manzur Al-Tarikhi Fi Fikr Sayyid Qutb.Imad al-din Khalil - 1994 - Dar Al-Qalam Al-Dar Al-Shamiyah.
The Political Thought of Qutb Al—Din Al—Shirazi.John Walbridge - 1992 - In Muhsin Mahdi & Charles E. Butterworth (eds.), The Political Aspects of Islamic Philosophy: Essays in Honor of Muhsin S. Mahdi. Distributed for the Center for Middle Eastern Studies of Harvard University by Harvard University Press. pp. 345--78.
Science and Technology in the Discourse of Sayyid Qutb.Ahmed Bouzid - 1996 - Social Epistemology 10 (3 & 4):289 – 304.
Aquinas on the Natural Inclination of Man to Offer Sacrifice to God.Sean B. Cunningham - 2012 - Proceedings of the American Catholic Philosophical Association 86:185-200.
Basic Principles of the Islamic Worldview.Sayyid Quṭb - 2006 - Islamic Publications International.
Agonistic Liberalism.John Gray - 1995 - Social Philosophy and Policy 12 (1):111-135.

Analytics

Added to PP index
2015-03-16

Total views
899 ( #6,015 of 2,448,108 )

Recent downloads (6 months)
87 ( #6,836 of 2,448,108 )

How can I increase my downloads?

Downloads

My notes