British Journal of Aesthetics 42 (1):73-82 (2002)

Saam Trivedi
Brooklyn College
I criticize Julian Dodd's Platonist conception of musical works as discovered eternal types, and defend and elaborate upon Jerrold Levinson's conception of musical works as creatable indicated types. I raise broadly three sorts of worries for Dodd. First, I argue that Dodd conflates types with Platonist universals in claiming that types are eternal and discovered. Secondly, I raise worries for Dodd's Platonist claim that musical works are discovered not created. Here I argue that Dodd's claim goes against our current musical practice. I then argue that Dodd's view leads to a false divide across the arts, and defend this claim from Dodd's criticisms. I also defend the claim that Dodd's view robs artists of the special status we give to them as creators, not merely creative discoverers. I suggest also that musical works can not only be created but can also plausibly cease to exist, which Dodd's Platonism would seem to deny. Thirdly and finally, I defend the conception of musical works as indicated types from Dodd's criticisms. Here I argue that Dodd's view is ontologically profligate. I also submit that Dodd is mistaken in thinking that indicated types have times as their constituents and thus must be events.
Keywords No keywords specified (fix it)
Categories (categorize this paper)
DOI 10.1093/bjaesthetics/42.1.73
Edit this record
Mark as duplicate
Export citation
Find it on Scholar
Request removal from index
Revision history

Download options

PhilArchive copy

Upload a copy of this paper     Check publisher's policy     Papers currently archived: 71,259
Through your library

References found in this work BETA

No references found.

Add more references

Citations of this work BETA

The Property Theory of Musical Works.Philip Letts - 2018 - Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism 76 (1):57-69.
The Philosophy of Music.Andrew Kania - 2008 - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
Fictionalism About Musical Works.Anton Killin - 2018 - Canadian Journal of Philosophy 48 (2):266-291.

View all 12 citations / Add more citations

Similar books and articles

Types, Continuants, and the Ontology of Music.Julian Dodd - 2004 - British Journal of Aesthetics 44 (4):342-360.
Music and Metaphysics.Saam Trivedi - 2008 - Metaphilosophy 39 (1):124–143.
Musical Works as Eternal Types.Julian Dodd - 2000 - British Journal of Aesthetics 40 (4):424-440.
Defending Musical Perdurantism.Ben Caplan & Carl Matheson - 2006 - British Journal of Aesthetics 46 (1):59-69.
Types, Indicated and Initiated.Robert Howell - 2002 - British Journal of Aesthetics 42 (2):105-127.
Works of Music: An Essay in Ontology.Julian Dodd - 2007 - Oxford University Press.
Defending Musical Platonism.Julian Dodd - 2002 - British Journal of Aesthetics 42 (4):380-402.


Added to PP index

Total views
71 ( #163,645 of 2,518,488 )

Recent downloads (6 months)
1 ( #408,186 of 2,518,488 )

How can I increase my downloads?


My notes