Acta Analytica 19 (33):45-54 (2004)
Modal arguments for incompatibility of freedom and determinism are typically based on the “transfer principle” for inability to act otherwise (Beta). The principle of agglomerativity (closure under conjunction introduction) is derivable from Beta. The most convincing counterexample to Beta is based on the denial of Agglomeration. The defender of the modal argument has two ways to block counterexamples to Beta: (i) use a notion of inability to act otherwise which is immune to the counterexample to agglomerativity; (ii) replace Beta with a logically stronger principle Beta 2. I argue that the second strategy fails because the strengthened principle and Agglomeration together entail Beta. So this strategy makes sense only if Beta 2 is applied without Agglomeration. But if Beta 2 is used without Agglomeration, then the incompatibilist will undercut the rationale for the premise of his argument. I illustrate this point with the analysis of Warfield (1996) and his use of Beta 2 in the so called direct argument for incompatibilism.
|Keywords||Determinism Freedom Incompatibilism Metaphysics Necessity Transfer Warfield, T|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
References found in this work BETA
The Metaphysics of Free Will: An Essay on Control.John Martin Fischer - 1994 - Blackwell.
A Reconsideration of an Argument Against Compatibilism.Thomas McKay & David Johnson - 1996 - Philosophical Topics 24 (2):113-122.
A Master Argument for Incompatibilism?Tomis Kapitan - 2002 - In Robert H. Kane (ed.), The Oxford Handbook of Free Will. Oxford University Press. pp. 127--157.
Citations of this work BETA
No citations found.
Similar books and articles
Towards a Probability Logic Based on Statistical Reasoning.Niki Pfeifer & G. D. Kleiter - 2006 - In Proceedings of the 11 T H Ipmu International Conference (Information Processing and Management of Uncertainty in Knowledge-Based Systems). pp. 2308--2315.
Reconstituting Beta Graphs Into an Efficacious System.Sun-Joo Shin - 1999 - Journal of Logic, Language and Information 8 (3):273-295.
Bounds for the Closure Ordinals of Essentially Monotonic Increasing Functions.Andreas Weiermann - 1993 - Journal of Symbolic Logic 58 (2):664-671.
The Irrelevance of Indeterministic Counterexamples to Principle Beta.Ted A. Warfield - 2000 - Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 61 (1):173 - 184.
Possible PCF Algebras.Thomas Jech & Saharon Shelah - 1996 - Journal of Symbolic Logic 61 (1):313-317.
A Weak Variation of Shelah's I[Ω₂].William J. Mitchell - 2004 - Journal of Symbolic Logic 69 (1):94-100.
Counterexamples to Principle Beta: A Response to Crisp and Warfield.Erik Carlson - 2003 - Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 66 (3):730-737.
Added to index2009-01-28
Total downloads43 ( #120,067 of 2,164,654 )
Recent downloads (6 months)1 ( #348,012 of 2,164,654 )
How can I increase my downloads?