The Contractualist Dilemma

Abstract

In moral and political philosophy many contractualist views appeal to hypothetical consent when justifying their proposed normative contents. In this paper I argue that all of them fail. In particular, I defend three claims. First, I consider and develop what I call the common objection to contractualism: that the stipulation of a hypothetical consent adds nothing to the independent reasons offered in contractualist procedures in favor of the normative content in question. Second, I hold that this objection gives rise to what I call the contractualist dilemma. Third, in light of the dilemma, I argue that contractualism should be understood in a non-justificatory way. These three claims might sound familiar to readers versed on the contractualist tradition. It is striking, however, how many contemporary authors continue to defend contractualism as a method of justification despite these arguments. This paper is thus a strong invitation to finally abandon the justificatory interpretation of this view.

Download options

PhilArchive



    Upload a copy of this work     Papers currently archived: 72,722

External links

Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server

Through your library

Analytics

Added to PP
2017-09-15

Downloads
9 (#958,531)

6 months
1 (#387,390)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author's Profile

Moises Vaca
National Autonomous University of Mexico

References found in this work

No references found.

Add more references

Citations of this work

No citations found.

Add more citations

Similar books and articles

Contractualism and Moral Criticism.Norman S. Care - 1969 - Review of Metaphysics 23 (1):85 - 101.
Contractualism and the Right to Aid.John M. Whelan - 1992 - Journal of Philosophical Research 17:427-442.
A Contractualist Defense of Rule Consequentialism.Sanford Levy - 2013 - Journal of Philosophical Research 38:189-201.
Contractualism and Moral Status.Phillips David - 1998 - Social Theory and Practice 24 (2):183-204.
Contractualism and the Conditional Fallacy.Jussi Suikkanen - 2014 - Oxford Studies in Normative Ethics 4:113-137.
Kontraktualistische Gerechtigkeitstheorien und die Idee eingebetteter Selbste.Martin Rechenauer - 2009 - Archiv für Rechts- Und Sozialphilosophie 95 (1):62-78.
Relational Contractualism and Future Persons.Michael Gibb - 2016 - Journal of Moral Philosophy 13 (2):135-160.
Contractualism, Politics, and Morality.Adam Hosein - 2013 - Acta Analytica 28 (4):495-508.
Contractualism and Our Duties to Nonhuman Animals.Matthew Talbert - 2006 - Environmental Ethics 28 (2):201-215.