The engagement of religion and biology: A case study in the mediating role of metaphor in the sociobiology of Lumsden & Wilson [Book Review]
Biology and Philosophy 15 (5):669-698 (2000)
I claim that explanations of human behaviour by Edward O. Wilsonand Charles Lumsden are constituted by a religiously functioningmetaphysics: emergent materialism. The constitutive effects areidentified using six criteria, beginning with a metaphorical re-description of dissimilarities between levels of organization interms of the lower level, and consist of conceptual andexplanatory reductions (CER). Wilson and Lumsden practice CER,even though CER is not required by emergent materialism. Theypreconceive this practice by a re-description which conflates thelevels of organization and explain failure of CER in terms oftechnical, not ontological or epistemological reasons. Iinterpret these three practices as a reaction of Wilson againsthis early Christian religious beliefs. Statements by Wilsonindicate this reaction ultimately constitutes his explanations ofsocial, moral and religious behaviour.Tested knowledge about matter at the lower level functions as ametaphysical belief when applied to the higher level becausethere it is untested. I offer twelve criteria for the diagnosisof religious functions of this metaphysical materialism, five ofwhich are satisfied. I show that the constitutive effects of thismaterialism in sociobiology are due to its religious functions,are beneficial for science and do not destroy its public nature.
|Keywords||analogy biological systems causation complexity emergent materialism hierarchy human sociobiology information metaphor methodological reduction ontological reduction part-whole relations physical systems religion and science self-organization social systems theory constitution theory reduction|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
References found in this work BETA
No references found.
Citations of this work BETA
No citations found.
Similar books and articles
Truth Hurts: The Sociobiology Debate, Moral Reading and the Idea of 'Dangerous Knowledge'.Petteri Pietikäinen - 2004 - Social Epistemology 18 (2-3):165-179.
Reducing Psychology While Maintaining its Autonomy Via Mechanistic Explanations.William Bechtel - 2007 - In M. Schouten & H. L. De Joong (eds.), The Matter of the Mind: Philosophical Essays on Psychology, Neuroscience and Reduction. Blackwell.
The Sociology of Sociobiology.Ronald de Sousa - 1990 - International Studies in the Philosophy of Science 4 (3):271 – 283.
The Sociobiology Muddle:On Human Nature. Edward O. Wilson; The Sociobiology Debate. Arthur L. Caplan; Human Sociobiology: A Holistic Approach. Daniel G. Freedman; Sociobiology: Sense or Nonsense? Michael Ruse. [REVIEW]Robert L. Simon - 1982 - Ethics 92 (2):327-.
Colleagues in Conflict: An 'in Vivo' Analysis of the Sociobiology Controversy. [REVIEW]Ullica Segerstrale - 1985 - Biology and Philosophy 1 (1):53-87.
E. O. Wilson After Twenty Years: Is Human Sociobiology Possible?Antony Flew - 1994 - Philosophy of the Social Sciences 24 (3):320-335.
Holism and Reduction in Sociobiology: Lessons From the Ants and Human Culture. [REVIEW]Edward O. Wilson & Charles J. Lumsden - 1991 - Biology and Philosophy 6 (4):401-412.
Added to index2009-01-28
Total downloads152 ( #30,794 of 2,168,638 )
Recent downloads (6 months)1 ( #346,816 of 2,168,638 )
How can I increase my downloads?